← Back to videos

This 1-hour Stanford lecture by Joel Peterson will teach you more about negotiation and getting what

Vipul Kumar Kewat

Vipul Kumar Kewat

@VipulKewatTech

November 18, 2026· 68:38

This 1-hour Stanford lecture by Joel Peterson will teach you more about negotiation and getting what you want than most people learn in years. Bookmark it and give it an hour, no matter what. https://t.co/bRFy7uKvXA

Transcript

Be a little bit more of a class
0:02
than a kind of a lecture or presentation
0:06
I learned something about marketing
0:07
because I was told that
0:09
the title of this initially was
0:12
How to Negotiate When You Absolutely Have to
0:16
Have the Deal
0:17
Well, that is a great ti- I mean
0:19
that's a title that you would
0:21
you'd come for. I mean
0:22
everybody would come to hear how you
0:24
how do you negotiate when you have to
0:26
have the deal?
0:28
You know
0:28
everybody wants to know how to do that
0:30
And they asked me
0:30
you know, what will you teach in that?
0:32
And I would say
0:32
don't get in that position
0:34
where you absolutely have to have the deal
0:37
So it'd be a very short session
0:39
So I changed, the session to the one that you
0:43
you signed up for
0:45
which is conducting, effective negotiations
0:48
So a little more pedestrian title
0:51
a little less exciting
0:52
but I think we'll go
0:53
over some things
0:54
here that may influence the way you think about
0:57
negotiations
1:02
so who in here likes to negotiate?
1:04
Raise of hands
1:08
So that's maybe twenty percent of the class
1:10
Who just dreads negotiation?
1:14
Now that's even a smaller percentage
1:16
So the rest of you are kind of
1:17
indifferent. You'll do it
1:19
you know, you'll eat your broccoli if you have to
1:21
but you're not looking forward to it
1:23
This is
1:24
negotiation is the vegetables of your business life
1:27
You'll do it, you know it's good for you
1:30
you know you have to do it
1:31
but you don't absolutely love it
1:33
So who, and let's just take a second on why
1:36
those of you who like it
1:37
why do you like it?
1:38
What is it you like about it?
1:42
Now the hands disappear. Yeah
1:44
Well, compared to my engineering field
1:46
when I knew everything was right or wrong
1:48
black or white, in negotiations, everything's gray
1:52
and nobody can say I'm wrong
1:53
Okay?
1:55
So you feel better about yourself
1:59
You
2:01
don't get any bad end
2:06
you don't get any... Exactly
2:07
Exactly. Yeah, right. So you're gonna improve your
2:11
your, the situation. Okay
2:17
so you negotiate
2:18
to improve whatever situation you're involved in
2:21
In complex situations
2:22
it's just rarely the case that you can
2:23
make a deal without some level of negotiation
2:26
So I look at it just as
2:27
as a means to the end
2:29
and getting to the end is kind of
2:30
the goal
2:31
On the flip side
2:32
doing win-win deals is really a lot of
2:34
fun
2:35
Okay
2:35
So you see it largely as eating your broccoli
2:38
but sometimes you do get to turn it
2:40
into dessert. Why do you think of the
2:45
first George Bush who made the comment about
2:48
how he hated eating broccoli?
2:49
So I actually like broccoli too
2:51
so. Yeah
3:01
Yeah
3:03
Yeah
3:05
So win-win agreements are fun
3:07
and you, and you can negotiate
3:08
the, the
3:10
the higher the percentage of deals you can
3:12
get that are win-win
3:13
the more you like it
3:18
So other. It does allow you to fashion
3:24
solutions according to usually different kinds of facts
3:29
different fact situations. So you get to be
3:32
you get to express some creativity
3:36
other things, yeah
3:39
Yeah, buildings
3:44
When you can disclose it some more
3:46
Yeah. And I'll bet you those of you
3:47
who said you didn't like
3:49
negotiations saw it as a way of destroying relationships
3:52
of stressing out relationships
3:55
So a lot of it depends on
3:56
on, you know
3:57
what are you doing to relationships
3:59
as you negotiate with other parties?
4:02
How about those of you who didn't like
4:03
let's get some more
4:04
things that you don't like about negotiation
4:06
For those who just said
4:07
man, I could do without this
4:09
what do you not like?
4:12
Yeah. It makes me very uncomfortable think
4:15
to think that
4:16
I do not have enough information
4:18
to get the most out of this negotiation
4:20
and, more often than not
4:22
I just regret the results
4:24
thinking I could have done better
4:26
Okay, so you look back on it and you say
4:29
shoot, I got taken
4:31
I didn't get as good a deal as
4:32
I might have gotten. I lost
4:36
Other things you don't like about
4:38
yeah. So that I'm hopeful that the person
4:42
on the other side is
4:43
where Is an intelligent team you're dealing with
4:46
but you do get the
4:48
what I call amateur
4:49
like if I pound on the table
4:51
that's an effective thing. That can get just
4:53
intellectually and emotionally tiresome to deal with
4:56
You can get abused in negotiations
4:58
And there's a whole lot of
4:59
there are a lot of issues around power
5:01
and information
5:02
If there's a disparity in power
5:05
leverage, information
5:07
and you're dealing with a party who's gonna
5:09
use that and take advantage of that
5:10
you can go out of the room feeling
5:12
abused
5:14
Yeah
5:17
Yeah
5:18
I actually met with Donald Trump in his
5:20
office in New York
5:21
about twenty years ago before he was a huge cheese
5:25
but he was, well, no
5:27
he still had the same hair
5:29
And actually
5:32
he tried to sell me an interest in
5:33
the Washington Generals
5:35
You know the Washington Generals?
5:37
This was a
5:38
USFL football team that had drafted Herschel Walker
5:43
And, so he was very proud of that
5:45
and he was trying to sell me an interest in that
5:48
and I didn't fall for it
5:49
So that's my qualification for teaching a class on negotiation
5:54
Actually, my qualifications is I
5:57
I have negotiated billions of dollars of transactions over the years
6:02
literally hundreds
6:03
if not a thousand different kinds of transactions
6:06
I was in the real estate business for twenty years
6:09
and
6:10
I was actually the chief financial officer of
6:12
a big real estate company for about ten
6:13
years. So I was negotiating debt deals and equity deals
6:17
and then partner departures and
6:20
solving litigation, and so my
6:22
my life was a diet of negotiate
6:25
just solid diet of negotiations
6:28
And then when I got done with that
6:29
I started buying companies
6:31
and it became a different diet of negotiations
6:33
So I've seen a lot of
6:35
different kinds of negotiations. I have experience
6:38
The feeling of looking forward to a day when I'm negotiating
6:43
with great anticipation
6:45
and
6:45
really loving it because I like the people
6:47
on the other side
6:48
I like trying to problem solve
6:50
I like being creative. I like all those
6:52
those elements
6:52
and I also have looked
6:54
at certain days of negotiating
6:56
where I dread it
6:58
I cannot wait to get the day behind
7:00
me
7:01
So there's nothing intrinsic about
7:03
negotiations that say you should like it or
7:05
not like it
7:07
I, I remember teaching a real estate
7:09
class here at Stanford about ten or twelve years ago
7:13
and asking the class
7:16
roughly the same question
7:17
but I did it in the form of
7:18
who of you likes to buy
7:21
a new car?
7:23
And that was the most highly correlated question
7:25
with who likes to negotiate and who doesn't
7:27
There are some people who absolutely
7:29
hate the process of buying a new car
7:32
because it feels like you come out a little dirty
7:36
you know?
7:37
You don't have the
7:38
it's an uneven information
7:40
uneven power, and whatever, so it can
7:42
it can be a bad experience
7:44
well
7:46
who here are expert negotiators?
7:49
Raise of hands
7:54
Every hand should go up
7:57
Every hand in the room should go up
7:59
You all are here in life because you
8:02
have been superb negotiators. You would not be in
8:06
but what is negotiating? Negotiation
8:08
is getting what you want at a price
8:10
that's acceptable to you
8:12
So you have paid prices
8:14
to be at this place in your
8:16
life that you're happy with
8:18
So you are expert negotiators
8:21
and I want to
8:21
ventilate that a little bit and let you
8:23
really kind of peer into what it is that you're
8:26
you've been so good at
8:27
But first of all
8:29
here's maybe a little bit of a map
8:31
for you to start thinking about the terrain
8:33
of negotiation
8:36
All of the conversations you have in life
8:38
if you think broadly about it
8:39
everything that you've done has been a negotiation
8:43
For those of you who are married
8:44
you're negotiating all the time
8:46
With your spouse, with your children, in your job
8:49
you're negotiating all the time
8:51
In school, you're negoti- I mean
8:52
conversations are in effect a give and take
8:56
And you, and there's a give-get transaction
8:59
and usually the more informal they are
9:01
the more successful people feel
9:03
When you do it with friends and family
9:05
usually they feel more successful
9:07
Then you get into these sort of styl
9:09
where we think about negotiations as entrepreneur
9:11
is in this area of stylized negotiations
9:14
where there are agreements
9:16
there are certain things that we negotiate
9:18
we sit down at a table
9:20
somebody takes notes, we write it out
9:23
and there are certain things that we trade
9:25
off
9:26
And then finally, very formal negotiations
9:29
These are typically ones that are done in arbitration or litigation
9:33
where there are rules of evidence
9:35
where it's a very structured
9:37
narrow thing. And that one is not a very fun one
9:40
although I've now spent four years in litigation
9:43
I'm good enough at it
9:44
In fact
9:44
I had
9:45
one attorney say that I was the best
9:47
witness he had ever run into
9:49
and I started liking negotiation
9:51
or, litigation after that
9:54
This was an opposing attorney
9:56
Too, so you feel pretty good about them
9:59
So what makes for successful negotiations
10:02
in across all of those?
10:05
Man
10:06
I recognize so many people from my past
10:08
in here. It's going to be hard not
10:09
to cold call on Angie here
10:12
F A, or Nicola
10:17
so what, what makes for successful negotiation?
10:20
If you think about successful negotiations
10:24
what do you think about?
10:25
I've just had a successful negotiation
10:27
What's your self-talk?
10:30
Yeah. Okay, expectations are, your expectations
10:35
you've set them the right way going in
10:37
they've been met, therefore you've achieved your objectives
10:41
That's a successful negotiation
10:43
Yeah. I would encourage us to purchase
10:47
provide perception, provide strategy
10:50
and then arrive at execution
10:52
Okay? It's also why I do think
10:56
your position is interesting
10:57
that he wants a lot of perception
10:58
Like, how do we perceive that?
11:02
How do we find out how that is
11:02
bottom line?
11:03
How that is something I should buy for?
11:05
And then we'll perceive strategy
11:06
and then we'll execute
11:08
Okay, so some of it is how you
11:10
how you define the terrain
11:11
how the other, how you and the other party perceive it
11:14
and then are you able to execute
11:16
in that perceived terrain
11:18
Bonnie?
11:20
When, when
11:21
it's easy to define what when is on your perspective
11:23
because you're happy
11:24
But I see when on the other side
11:26
is that the person
11:26
that the residual effect after they walked out the room
11:29
And as time goes on that they're not
11:30
upset
11:32
and don't try to undermine the negotiate whatever
11:34
the result was. So they were happy too
11:36
Okay
11:36
so you are thinking more broadly than a
11:38
lot of business people think about negotiation
11:41
I mean
11:41
these are what I would call enlightened
11:44
comments about negotiation. Here's what most business people
11:47
are negotiating
11:50
This is the essence of most business agreements
11:54
these five things
11:55
So they're focused on getting the best price
11:59
getting the most attractive terms
12:01
making sure that whatever timeframes for execution or deliverables
12:05
whatever are acceptable, making sure the warranties are in place
12:10
and then if things go wrong
12:12
they've got remedies
12:14
They may be legal remedies
12:15
they may be economic remedies
12:17
they're probably a combination of both
12:19
So most business negotiators
12:20
which is in this stylized category in the middle
12:23
is so focused on
12:25
me getting what I want in these five
12:27
areas
12:28
And people don't think more broadly
12:31
than that. If
12:38
people who do a lot of negotiating around
12:40
these things talk about these techniques
12:44
has anybody
12:47
not run into these before as
12:49
sort of things that are taught
12:51
in negotiation classes? Are any of these new
12:53
to any of you
12:54
surprising?
12:57
The bathroom one is a
12:59
is a commonly used technique
13:01
Feed the person a lot of water and
13:03
a lot of food
13:05
and then just keep talking
13:07
keep the pressure in. So using the bath
13:09
bathroom breaks is a powerful
13:11
if you're using techniques
13:13
you know, the
13:14
and what do I mean by plane?
13:17
They've got a plane to catch
13:19
their schedule, exactly
13:21
They've got to catch a plane
13:23
and so you just carry on the negotiation
13:26
You speak slowly
13:28
You make things drag out
13:30
you disagree at the last minute
13:32
just as they're running for their place
13:33
Oh, you do the Colombo thing
13:35
You know, oh, one more thing
13:38
you know
13:39
have any of you been
13:40
subject to any of these?
13:44
What does it feel like?
13:49
You have to assess whether it's
13:50
it's, it's
13:52
it's
13:53
almost incompetence or is it actual bad faith?
13:56
And that can be difficult
13:57
and it's annoying to have to even have
13:58
that experience. Either case
14:00
what do you, how do you feel?
14:02
If you're dealing with an incompetent party or a bad actor
14:07
it makes you angry
14:10
Very few people don't recognize these
14:13
If you're on the other side of the table
14:14
it's not like, oh my gosh
14:16
what is happening? I don't know
14:18
I don't understand. This is sure working on me
14:21
you know?
14:22
Most of the time you perceive immediately these
14:25
techniques
14:27
And you resent them
14:28
You're angry about them. So
14:30
in terms of techniques that people teach
14:32
you know
14:32
I think these are anti-successful agreement techniques
14:37
You may get a deal done
14:39
but you're unlikely to get a deal that is lasting
14:42
enduring, flexible, where you build relationships
14:45
where you create solutions
14:47
But these are used all the time
14:49
mostly by investment bankers. I'm just kidding
14:54
Sorry, sorry, I know
14:58
Could you turn the tape off up there?
15:01
Another technique which I've run into quite a
15:03
lot dealing with competitors
15:04
which is the, during a set of complex
15:07
long, long negotiations maybe over the course of months
15:10
the
15:13
you
15:13
you discover that in the course of the
15:14
supposedly good faith negotiation
15:17
the competitor, for example
15:18
has been
15:19
actually promoting something completely different or talking to Somebody else
15:23
and the explanation you get when you protest is
15:26
I am very sorry
15:27
we had no idea that was going on
15:29
Yeah. Improvisation, you're innocent. Yeah
15:32
Or, or just innocent, you know, I had no idea
15:34
or, oh my gosh
15:36
Yeah
15:37
Yeah. Which puts you on your heels
15:39
puts you at a disadvantage
15:40
maybe there are others
15:42
Anybody in here experience other
15:44
te-
15:44
obvious techniques that are being used
15:46
to gain power? Yeah. John
15:55
Yeah. I
15:59
bet there are a lot of interesting stories
16:01
There's another one. So
16:03
yeah
16:04
Sorry
16:07
There's, development in terms of
16:09
having experience having had a negotiation
16:11
in China
16:12
where I was sitting across the table from a gentleman who
16:15
spoke
16:16
or at least didn't claim to have spoken
16:18
any English
16:19
And so I had a translator
16:20
fortunately, and
16:21
so that was one kind of was an
16:23
interesting barrier because I was pretty sure that he understood
16:26
English and, a variety of reasons
16:29
and, smoke was also another one
16:32
He's an avid smoker
16:33
and I can understand smoke
16:35
and
16:35
I tried
16:36
my hardest to make sure that he didn't know that because
16:39
that certainly affected kind of the way
16:42
you know, how much time I wanted to spend in this
16:43
you know, four by eight room
16:46
It was very interesting. So making things physically
16:48
uncomfortable or getting a leg up through language
16:50
There's another way that I see language used
16:53
and that is abusive language
16:55
You know, people that start dropping F bombs or shouting
16:59
you know, cursing at you, whatever
17:01
they believe they get a leg up
17:03
And in some ways
17:04
most of us kind of react
17:05
we
17:05
we go a little bit on our heels
17:07
when somebody starts
17:08
cursing at us or they raise their voice
17:10
or something. I mean
17:11
as tough as you may be
17:13
if somebody starts doing that
17:14
there's something in the inner child
17:17
of all of us that recoils a little
17:19
bit and is back on our heels a little
17:21
Now
17:21
it can cause you to come back
17:23
in
17:23
like manner. It can cause you to
17:26
get to that level yourself
17:27
which may or may not be a good
17:28
thing. Comment?
17:30
So
17:30
I had actually the opposite happen to me
17:32
once where we were having issues and then
17:35
we couldn't come to an agreement
17:37
And then they came back and they were actually
17:40
you know, they couldn't do more
17:42
more than what they were saying
17:51
If they gave me everything
17:53
so they would treat me with kindness
17:54
and then they went home and back and
17:55
and changed it again. So it was the
17:56
opposite of using the abusive language
17:57
So it's kind of the limp leg
17:58
you know
17:58
and yeah. Where people use different techniques to
18:00
deceive. Andy?
18:01
So do I have a feeling you're going
18:03
to tell us
18:03
ways to actually do this that aren't these ways
18:05
but
18:06
let's use these guys examples where you actually
18:08
are faced with people like this on the
18:09
other side of the table
18:11
and how do you actually
18:13
take control or sort of set it on a positive tone
18:15
especially if you're in a situation where you're
18:16
sort of feeling like
18:17
this is the company I really want to buy
18:19
or this is the job that I really want to get
18:22
and you don't really have as many options
18:23
but these people are actually coming at you
18:25
with these techniques
18:26
What would you advise us to do?
18:28
Well, let's have the group
18:29
I'll, I'll give you my
18:30
the way I react to it
18:31
but anybody in the group
18:32
you know
18:33
somebody is using
18:34
one or more of these on you
18:37
Yeah
18:39
So calling them on it is one really
18:40
thing today
18:41
You know, I've actually done this in a
18:42
in a litigation where
18:45
the opposing attorney was deposing me
18:49
and he stood up and got right in
18:51
my face and started to shout at me
18:53
He said, why did you do such and such?
18:58
And, you know, it really is off-putting
19:00
And you're, you're, the, the
19:02
all it shows in the transcript is
19:04
why did you do such and such?
19:06
That's all it shows
19:09
That's
19:10
all it shows. And if you answer
19:12
the way you're feeling
19:13
when somebody gets in your face and shouts
19:15
at you in accu- in an accusatory way
19:16
you say, well, you son of a gun
19:18
I'll tell you the reason
19:19
You know
19:19
and you'll do it in a way that
19:20
isn't effective
19:21
The most effective thing that I found was
19:23
exactly what you're saying. I say
19:25
why are you standing up and raising your voice?
19:28
I mean, that goes on the record
19:30
But it's, so that's, that's the most
19:34
You know
19:35
copy down way of doing exactly what you're
19:37
saying is
19:38
you really call them out in a nice
19:39
way. Why are you raising your voice?
19:42
What makes you shout about that question?
19:43
Why are you standing up?
19:45
Why are you pacing the
19:46
floor as you get all of it on the record?
19:48
Now
19:49
you don't need to get it on the
19:50
record in a normal negotiation
19:51
but calling them on it is one thing
19:53
What's another way that you could deal with
19:54
that?
19:56
Questions
19:58
Questions are very effective. You know
20:00
just asking, just posing questions, you know, that's always a
20:04
a very inoffensive way of taking the volume level down
20:08
getting information, cooling people off
20:12
Another way
20:15
When you're in this type of mode
20:18
the other person's not in good faith
20:19
and most negotiations we're going to be doing
20:21
you need to have a relationship
20:22
and
20:22
the relationship is usually a lot more important
20:24
than the actual deal you finally end up
20:25
with in a lot of cases
20:27
So I mean
20:27
I think you do have to call them
20:28
on it. You have to say
20:29
you know, what's your purpose here?
20:30
And you guys, if he's doing one and you're doing another
20:33
it doesn't make sense. You guys have to
20:35
be both wanting a deal and both wanting the best
20:37
you know, win-win. And if they get there
20:39
Some people have such power and such an advantage
20:43
and you really do need the deal
20:46
that they get away with more
20:47
that it, it's tough to raise them to that level
20:49
when there's such a disparity in terms of information or power
20:53
that it can be very tough to do
20:55
I'll tell you what I try to do
20:56
is make it completely ineffective
20:59
Just make it so either I ignore it
21:02
I just don't pay attention
21:04
to what it is they're doing
21:05
By that, I mean I don't drink water
21:08
you know, I am able to outla
21:10
My bladder is better than their bladder
21:13
you know, or I
21:17
I will plan my trip with an extra night of
21:20
hotel room
21:21
and I'll have an extra flight out the
21:23
next day. So I'm not anxious about
21:25
I'll let them know I'm leaving at five
21:26
o'clock tonight. That oftentimes they'll push the thing up
21:29
and I just don't sweat it
21:30
We stay, and then, then pretty soon it
21:32
to me, it becomes a question of
21:34
well, let's keep staying here
21:35
let's keep working
21:36
You know, I've missed my plane
21:38
let's work, it's eleven at night
21:39
no problem, I can keep working
21:41
Well, I mean
21:41
you kind of
21:42
make it so that the game that they've
21:44
set up hurts them
21:46
So they really pay the price for whatever
21:48
game they set. So make it ineffective
21:51
So these techniques
21:53
really can sometimes work
21:55
marginally in the short run on some people
21:59
but they're not really very powerful long-term techniques
22:03
Now, if you look at textbook discussions of negotiation
22:06
you run into these terms
22:08
and I'm not going to talk about the tech
22:09
I want to talk really today about very practical
22:12
real-world situations, but these are
22:15
this is the terminology
22:16
So
22:17
I know some of you are going to
22:18
take classes or have taken classes in negotiation
22:21
These will not be unfamiliar
22:23
terms to you in the lexicon of
22:25
negotiation
22:28
So here are some practical keys to successful negotiation
22:31
and these will look just so simple-minded
22:33
which is, in fact, what most really practical things are
22:36
born of
22:37
experience. But the first thing is
22:39
negotiate with the right party
22:40
I'm going to tell you
22:41
a half a dozen stories here before we wrap up
22:45
where you'll see how I learned these particular lessons
22:48
I think
22:49
But get with the right party
22:51
You would be amazed at how many negotiations
22:54
go on with the wrong party
22:56
with the unempowered lieutenant
22:58
with somebody who really is not the
23:00
the decision maker
23:01
whatever. So figure out who the right party is
23:04
and are you talking with the right party?
23:07
secondly, is become a trusted negotiator
23:09
And I put here that's a function of CCP
23:11
and my students will recognize it as a function of character
23:15
competence, and power. For somebody to be trusted
23:19
they have to be high character
23:21
they have to be competent
23:22
and they have to be empowered
23:23
to make a decision
23:25
So you want it
23:26
the right party for you to
23:27
negotiate with is somebody you can trust
23:30
The right party for them
23:31
is that you must be also trusted
23:34
So if you want to enter high quality negotiations
23:37
getting high levels of trust based on character
23:39
competence
23:40
and empowerment are really important things to assess
23:44
Then know your own BATNA
23:46
What's a BATNA?
23:49
In unison
23:51
That's the alternative to negotiated agreement
23:54
Okay
23:55
this is a term that was developed by
23:56
Fisher and Urey in 1981 out of the Harford negotiation study
24:01
which
24:01
they really found that if people could go
24:04
into a negotiation
24:05
with an idea of what is their best alternative to this
24:09
this negotiation working out successfully
24:11
they came out with better end results
24:13
You go in with far more confidence
24:16
I've taken it to another level
24:17
What I go into negotiations now is I figure out
24:20
I don't know it for sure
24:22
but I try to assess
24:24
what is the other party's partner
24:26
So I really think hard about
24:28
what is it they want to achieve
24:30
and what are their options
24:32
because that really helps you
24:33
kind of assess the whole thing
24:35
You're not just thinking my agenda
24:37
my agenda, my agenda. Here's what I want
24:39
price term, remedies
24:41
warranty. This is what I need
24:42
And so many negotiators are going in with
24:44
their own agenda
24:46
Well
24:46
go in and think about what is the
24:48
lay of the land for the other party
24:50
and that helps
24:53
We'll talk a little bit later about Fisher and Urey's map
24:55
but I think there are three or four
24:56
suggestions that they make
24:58
that are kind of their broad map
25:00
that are really very helpful
25:02
Discern the difference between battles and wars
25:06
what, what we used to call the elephant-ant
25:08
Some people don't know the elephants from the
25:10
ants. Have you ever negotiated with somebody
25:13
for whom every deal point
25:15
is something that they have to win?
25:18
You know, everything is compet- everything that's brought up
25:20
they have to win every deal point
25:22
I'm here
25:23
here to submit to you that that's a
25:24
really dumb way to negotiate
25:26
That this is a given to- you're- if
25:28
if you're gonna try to develop relationships the way Nikola said
25:31
or if you're gonna
25:32
try to come out with creative solutions or whatever
25:35
you really don't want this
25:36
I have to win every deal point thing
25:38
So know where the elephants are and where
25:40
the ants are. Be willing to u- to lose
25:43
some battles to win the war
25:45
Yeah, Michelle
25:48
Up in first place
25:49
so isn't
25:49
wouldn't it be to my advantage just to
25:51
put points there that I know I'm
25:53
I don't feel so strongly about?
25:54
Yeah. Wouldn't the other party be doing the
25:55
same thing?
25:56
They should be. And you should
25:58
I mean, in really effective sort of win-win negotiations
26:01
you share with what you're trying to achieve
26:04
Lee Iacocca has a great line
26:06
you know, he was the guy that turned around Chrysler
26:08
and he said, you know, when I want to achieve something
26:11
I tell the other party exactly what it
26:13
is I'm trying to achieve
26:14
and what price I'm willing to pay to
26:17
achieve it
26:18
And that's really kind of the starting point where it's
26:20
it's sharing info
26:21
so there's a lot more sharing of information
26:23
in that kind of a model of negotiation
26:26
It doesn't always
26:27
it's not always something you can do
26:30
and then I, you know, getting back to these techniques
26:32
I would say don't worry too much about
26:34
techniques. You have to be aware of them
26:36
You have to be
26:36
and it tells you something
26:37
If somebody's using, I
26:39
I always think when somebody's shouting at me
26:41
or walking out of the room or throwing things
26:43
there's information in that. It's like I
26:46
I had a partner one time
26:48
in the real estate business who looked at
26:49
a joint venture document that was this thick
26:52
and he looked at it and he
26:53
picked it up and he says
26:55
in any document that's that thick
26:57
there's something in it for me
27:01
And in a way
27:02
anybody who's throwing
27:04
things and screaming and shouting and slamming doors
27:06
or locking you in rooms or anything like that
27:10
there's something in that for you
27:13
You know, you can get the high moral ground
27:15
you can at least get information
27:16
so don't worry too much about them
27:18
but be aware of them
27:19
And then really understand what the other party
27:21
this is
27:22
kind of back to the figuring the other person's pattern
27:24
but the more you can understand their values
27:26
and I'll tell you stories in a minute
27:28
that illustrate each of these
27:29
but the more you can understand
27:31
really what it is that drives them
27:33
what's important to them
27:35
the more likely you are to craft
27:37
a solution to things that
27:39
satisfies what it is that's important to them
27:44
so here, you've all seen this before
27:48
just to pause on it for a second
27:49
those of you who
27:51
dread negotiations probably have experienced
27:55
some of this win-lose experience
27:59
Those of you who
28:00
said you really enjoyed them have probably experienced more of the
28:04
the left-hand column
28:07
Okay, so here's
28:08
seven situations that have sort of illustrated these points for me
28:13
and I only tell you these not because
28:15
I've had some unique negotiating experience
28:17
but because you may recognize
28:19
in some of these things your own experience
28:21
you may be able to tie it into
28:22
your own experience and internalize it
28:25
in your own way so that it really
28:27
does belong to you. The first one
28:28
I
28:29
I taught a negotiation session
28:31
in the real estate course here at Stanford
28:34
a number of years ago
28:36
and I had a version one and version
28:37
two of this. In version one
28:40
the instructions were
28:42
I want you all to have fun
28:43
So this was the three-party negotiation
28:45
There was a buyer
28:47
there were two or three properties
28:49
a buyer, a seller, and a lender
28:50
and they had to come up with a tripartite agreement
28:53
And
28:54
so everybody went off in these negotiating teams
28:56
and made deals. The instructions were have fun
29:00
be creative, learn everything you can about real estate and everything
29:03
and then just report back on your experiences
29:05
Well, here's what happened
29:07
There were reasonable deals made
29:09
they were made quickly
29:10
they were relatively easy to understand and document
29:13
and there was a lot of camaraderie
29:15
People came out of it saying
29:16
man, this is, this was a fun exercise
29:19
we like each other. Aren't Stanford MBAs cool?
29:23
Well, I just really love my classmates
29:25
So that was kind of the outcome
29:26
So that was the negotiation 1.0
29:28
So then we changed the instructions
29:31
Okay, the objective is to win
29:34
You know, you're going into this negotiation
29:36
the idea is you want to win
29:37
Your grade's going to be influenced by it
29:40
and the results are going to be published in rank order
29:43
and you need to make a report on
29:44
how you feel about it
29:45
What would you guess the change in results was?
29:51
Yeah, fewer deals were made
29:54
They were made more slowly
29:55
a lot more time was expended
29:57
I mean, tons more time
29:59
People said this negotiating exercise took longer and
30:01
was tougher than anything they had done
30:04
at Stanford
30:08
People were frustrated, and they hated their classmates
30:12
They said
30:13
I will
30:13
never do business with these turkeys again
30:16
I had no idea these people were such jerks
30:19
You know, and so it fundamentally changed by the mindset
30:22
and I set up the mindset
30:24
I mean, it's my fault, but The economic outcomes weren't any
30:28
but they were fewer
30:29
as somebody pointed out
30:31
A lot more complex deals
30:33
a lot of them were unworkable
30:34
undocumentable, unenforceable, and the interpersonal relationships were strained
30:39
So you can see by having this mindset
30:41
of we've got to win
30:42
and it's zero sum
30:44
and it was defined. I mean
30:45
there was so, I mean
30:46
there's so few things in most business negotiations
30:48
there was so little data that was price
30:50
terms, timeframes, warranties
30:53
and remedies were about the only thing
30:55
people could work with. Well
30:56
I mean, they went in and just pummeled each other
30:58
just beat each other to bloody pulps
31:01
So that's, the first story
31:06
And I'll let you draw your own conclusions
31:07
from these. The second one is
31:09
when I was first starting in business
31:11
I had a deal that I was working on in Asca
31:14
or they say Athca
31:15
Spain
31:17
Did I do that right?
31:17
Any of the Spanish speakers?
31:19
Athca
31:21
and we were going into a bank
31:22
there to borrow money
31:24
And we walked in and it was clear
31:26
within a few minutes that they really weren't
31:27
quite expecting us
31:29
there. So they ushered us into this office
31:31
with a guy that
31:32
you said, oh, well, you know
31:33
and so he sat down to listen to
31:35
us. And as we were sitting there negotiating over
31:38
financing this office building
31:40
two guys in white
31:41
coats came in and they took the painting
31:43
off the wall
31:45
Then a few minutes later
31:46
they came back in and took the credenza
31:48
And then they unplugged the phone and walked
31:50
out with the phone
31:52
Pretty soon they came in and took the desk
31:53
put it on a dolly
31:54
and went out with it
31:55
We're sitting there in these chairs talking
31:57
and all of the furniture's been moved out
32:00
Well
32:00
it turns out this guy was not
32:02
really
32:03
the person who had anything to do with
32:04
it. He was just a courtesy party
32:07
We said, well, these guys are here
32:08
they're from the United States
32:10
make them feel good
32:11
and so the negotiation went on
32:13
Well, this kind of, I will tell you
32:14
my point on this is it goes back
32:15
to
32:16
make sure you're negotiating with the right party
32:18
We had absolutely the right
32:19
this guy could not have made any deal with us whatsoever
32:22
but we didn't check it out
32:23
so we sat there
32:24
talking across an empty
32:25
office about a deal that was never going to happen
32:28
Well
32:28
that's an extreme example of something that we
32:31
all do a lot of time
32:32
We end up negotiating with parties without power
32:36
without the ability to make a decision
32:38
So you really want to think that through
32:40
The third one, was also early on in my career
32:44
I was a
32:45
chief financial officer in my late twenties of a big
32:49
big company. I was supposed to
32:51
make a joint venture with a life insurance company
32:55
And, so I'd studied all the joint ventures had been
32:58
I'd figured out what
32:59
I wanted on this deal and what a win-win
33:01
I mean, I had all
33:02
I was steeped in all these things
33:03
and so I sat down with the
33:05
the very senior, fifty-ish life insurance executive
33:09
and we started to go through the deal points
33:11
and there were eight or ten of them
33:12
And about, after I'd been said
33:14
no, we're not going to do that
33:15
and about the eighth deal point
33:17
I rose
33:17
I rose him on the ninth deal point and said
33:19
you know
33:20
we really need to have this one
33:21
You've said no on eight of them
33:22
and he said, Joel, sit down
33:24
just take notes
33:26
Your job here is just to take notes
33:30
You know, we're not negotiating anything
33:33
Just take notes. We're the life company
33:35
We've got all the money
33:37
You're just the developer. Take notes
33:40
And so it was clear to me that
33:41
what that negotiation was about
33:43
That negotiation was not going to be one in
33:46
in that series of discussions
33:49
but I was really going to just document
33:51
it in a way that we had
33:53
a chance to do
33:55
our business and we had options in the future
33:59
you know? So
33:59
that wasn't the only option that I had
34:03
Limited partners
34:06
I
34:07
I recall early on thinking that I wanted to develop a
34:11
a brand
34:12
I wanted to be seen as a certain kind of
34:14
negotiator
34:17
And
34:21
I
34:21
part of my brand was going to be
34:22
that I would calculate exactly what a deal was worth
34:25
and then I wouldn't budge on the price
34:27
I was
34:27
I wanted to be known as somebody
34:29
who knew the value of
34:30
what it was I was offering
34:32
And so if I said
34:33
this is a million dollar investment
34:35
I didn't want to settle for nine hundred
34:37
and fifty thousand
34:38
You know
34:39
I really wanted to say
34:40
it's a million dol- And I guess
34:42
if you want to trade two nickels for a dime
34:44
I'll do that
34:45
but I'm not gonna trade
34:46
a dime for one nickel
34:48
So I really wanted that to be in my brain
34:50
cause I realized I was gonna be in
34:51
this business
34:52
a long time and do hundreds of deals
34:54
So in, in negotiating with these limited partners
34:56
I became very stiff on this
35:00
And it was only when I got options
35:03
and, and what happened to me in this
35:04
in, in one case was a guy said
35:07
well, I'm not gonna do the deal
35:08
I need to do the deal at nine
35:09
hundred and fifty thousand
35:10
not a million
35:12
I went out that night
35:14
and called another limited partner investor group and said
35:17
I'll tell you what
35:18
if you'll do this deal at a million dollars
35:21
I can document the deal tonight
35:23
and I can give you all these other things
35:25
but I need the agreement tonight
35:27
So when the guy called up the next
35:28
day to resume negotiations
35:30
I could say, sorry
35:31
I've already done that deal
35:33
So I was able to establish that I
35:35
don't move on price
35:37
And it worked for a while until the
35:39
we
35:39
the guy and I became really good friends
35:41
We ended up doing three hundred
35:43
deals together over a twenty year lifespan
35:46
so a lot of transactions
35:47
About fifty deals or so into it
35:49
he said, Joel, he says, I just gotta tell ya
35:53
I like to negotiate price
35:55
I don't feel good
35:57
unless I can negotiate price
35:59
So if you want it to be a million dollars
36:01
tell me it's a million fifty
36:04
Just tell me it's a million fifty
36:06
I'll come back with a million
36:08
and then we'll both feel good
36:11
And so we negotiated that
36:12
The last two hundred and fifty deals we did
36:15
I would go in about five or
36:16
eight percent higher than what I would accept
36:19
He would knock it down
36:20
he'd feel good, and I'd feel good
36:22
So
36:22
y-you're kind of going in and having
36:24
sort of a
36:26
Sort of a reasonable ba- what I'm calling ROR
36:29
or rules of the road
36:31
If you're gonna have serial negotiations with somebody
36:34
develop rules of the road
36:38
Senior partner, departure
36:41
This is a situation
36:42
there was a billion dollar transaction
36:45
So it was a big deal
36:47
and this was fifteen or twenty years ago
36:49
So it was a
36:49
a very significant transaction
36:51
and the partner came to me and said
36:52
you know, I want to, let's agree, going into this negotiation
36:58
let's agree on values
37:00
Let's agree what these properties are worth
37:02
and then we'll make the trade
37:04
And on this particular case
37:06
I thought, you know, the biggest mistake we could make was
37:09
would be to agree on the values
37:11
Let's disagree on the values
37:13
So you set up whatever
37:14
you know the properties better than I do
37:16
you value them however you wish
37:19
and then I'll select
37:21
And the very fact that we didn't agree
37:23
on values
37:25
allowed me to select deals where I thought
37:27
I was getting more than my fair share
37:30
He then was able to
37:31
because he said that he was fine
37:34
with the, with the deal
37:35
because he'd represented what the values were
37:37
And it was just applying the percentage to
37:38
the values
37:39
he'd set. So we were able to get a transaction
37:42
done
37:44
My departure. So I left the Crow organization
37:47
with the reputation of being a conciliator
37:50
with the reputation of being reasonable
37:52
with the reputation of being a win-win dealer
37:54
I'd
37:55
settled all the litigation that Crow had had for twenty years
37:58
the parting departures. I was seen as somebody
38:00
who was litigation-averse
38:03
And because that had become my brand
38:06
my negotiating brand, when it came to that
38:09
they filed litigation
38:10
Against me, realizing that he'll never fight
38:14
This guy's such a pussy
38:15
such a conciliator, he's such a giver
38:18
and he'll make everything
38:20
I really had no place to go
38:22
I had set myself up with my brand
38:24
So I want, from that
38:25
I want you to think
38:26
very carefully about the brand
38:28
you want to have
38:30
The last story is one that I think
38:32
you'll remember
38:35
we had four years of litigation
38:37
So I now have a new brand
38:41
I'm now known as the ferret
38:45
No, it's, it's interesting because I
38:47
I think what my brand has become is
38:49
I am somebody who is very reasonable
38:52
who will do win-win negotiations
38:54
but if you get to the point where
38:55
you cross me and my principles
38:57
or if you
38:58
do something that I really think is completely unfair
39:00
then I become very stiff
39:02
So you don't want to get into litigation with me
39:04
but you don't need to
39:06
So that's
39:07
that's a better brand than the brand I had before
39:09
which was the guy will never sue
39:11
He will never get into litigation
39:13
So you really want to think carefully
39:14
because that brand
39:15
and part of my message here is that
39:17
there are no episodic negotiations
39:21
You may think it's an episode
39:23
You may think you're going in and having
39:25
a one-off deal with somebody
39:27
That person talks to somebody else who talks
39:29
to somebody else who talks to somebody else
39:31
and pretty soon everything is
39:33
we live in a very connected world
39:35
So think
39:36
carefully. If you're doing a lot of negotiation for a living
39:39
think very carefully about the brand you want to have
39:43
Now, I apologize to my students
39:46
former students for this next one
39:48
because several of you have seen this
39:49
but I had a
39:52
a negotiation with my daughter
39:55
over this last topic
39:57
So I'm out here teaching at Stanford
39:59
and I come out for basically ten weeks
40:02
when I teach here
40:03
and so she's back in another state
40:04
and we correspond by email
40:06
I get back a couple of times
40:07
She and my wife get out a couple of times
40:09
but we're basically away from each other
40:11
So here I get this email from her
40:15
Dear Dad
40:17
do you hear that I'm getting a rat?
40:19
Won't that be cool?
40:21
The pet store lady said that you can
40:22
train rats to fetch and stay
40:25
I want her to get mice because they're
40:26
cuter and don't have a disgusting tail
40:28
but mice just run away
40:29
and they never become your friends
40:31
Rats will sleep on you
40:32
and I'm sure, Dad
40:33
you'll become great friends with my rats
40:37
I'm thinking of naming them Ritzy and Scraps
40:41
Won't that be cute?
40:42
And you can even see them when they're
40:44
tiny babies
40:44
Take deep breaths if you're getting nervous
40:47
I will pay for them and the cage
40:49
with my very own money
40:50
All you and Mom have to do is buy the food
40:52
which really doesn't cost much
40:54
I've already done everything else
40:56
I think I'm ready. It's okay
40:57
I can take care of them
40:58
I've proven I can take care of animals
41:00
I even sweep up the cat's barf
41:03
I can handle it
41:05
So
41:06
you can trust me to take care of
41:08
Ritzy and Scratch. They already have names
41:11
I hope you're doing well at Stanford
41:13
Isn't this warm and fuzzy?
41:15
I'm doing well here. Same normal things
41:16
practicing soccer, whining to mom about getting rats
41:20
Just so you know
41:21
she already said yes
41:25
Is this a negotiator?
41:27
This is a eleven-year-old kid
41:29
I mean, so some of this stuff
41:30
when I asked her who are the expert negotiators
41:33
I promise you
41:34
we are born knowing something about negotiations
41:38
Just so you know
41:38
she, oh yeah
41:39
I'm sure she's sick of the same conversations
41:41
Can I get a rat
41:42
mom? Please, I'll do my practicing
41:44
That's my secret in life
41:46
Promise to do my practicing
41:48
Love, Elise
41:49
So here's this This is the initial volley
41:53
This is the negotiating position
41:56
She's kind of laid out her negotiating position
41:58
So you're sitting out here fifteen hundred miles away thinking
42:03
no way
42:06
She has crossed a barrier I'm unwilling
42:09
to cross. So here's my response
42:11
and I want you to notice
42:12
this because this is a nego- this is
42:14
a real life negotiation
42:16
and I'm going to have you predict how
42:18
it came out
42:22
What's that?
42:25
Good point
42:27
Dear Elise, are you nuts?
42:30
I've been killing rats at the house in
42:32
Woodside. They are not cute
42:33
They're not nice. They're not controllable
42:36
They stink. They eat everything
42:37
They make little back poops everywhere
42:40
and I have to clean up the mess
42:41
Just this week
42:42
I bought some decon
42:43
to put out where the rats live
42:46
The next day
42:47
I found a dead rat near the pool
42:48
and another one trapped in the garage
42:50
Just to be clear how
42:51
about how I feel
42:51
I must inform you that we smashed its
42:53
head into the shrub
43:00
I'm a negotiator, come on
43:04
It was fat and ugly
43:05
By the way
43:06
I think its name was something like ritzy
43:10
In any event
43:11
one of the big reasons I was getting
43:12
so excited about coming home was to get
43:15
away from the rats out there
43:17
Now I may as well stay
43:19
huh?
43:20
See how hurt?
43:21
I'm just hurt. I'm appealing to this young daughter
43:25
now, what would you like next
43:27
a python?
43:28
Or how about some Ebola virus?
43:31
Or maybe you could raise maggots
43:33
Anyway, I still love you and miss you
43:35
and we'll see you next week
43:36
Love, Dad
43:38
So how did this negotiation come out?
43:42
Predict
43:43
What's that?
43:45
She gets the rats
43:46
exactly
43:48
She got the rats
43:50
Now
43:50
why
43:51
would an expert professional negotiator
43:54
with ten billion dollars worth of deals
43:56
under my belt
43:58
give in to this eleven-year-old kid on some
44:00
stinking rats?
44:04
That's a great point
44:09
besides, her mom had already said yes
44:10
so a real imbalance of power
44:14
To me
44:15
this is the difference between knowing the elephants
44:17
and the ants
44:18
You know
44:18
I was willing to lose a battle to
44:20
win the war
44:21
And the war, what I wanted, winning for me
44:24
defining winning for me was raising a child who's responsible
44:29
who loves me
44:30
who will listen to me on things that
44:31
really do matter
44:33
And so I was really willing to kind
44:34
of take a different
44:36
now get, now the really gratifying part about this story is
44:39
in the end
44:40
she gave the rats back to the pet
44:42
store lady
44:44
after the pet store lady had told her
44:46
she would be feeding them to the snakes
44:48
So she disliked the rats as much as
44:50
I did in the end
44:52
and she came away saying
44:53
Dad, you were right about the rats
44:57
So, now
45:02
she
45:02
I arrived home and the rats were there
45:07
And she said, no, no, it was done
45:11
It's a done deal. Mom had already said yes
45:14
It was, do you want to hold them
45:15
Dad?
45:18
No, I think I'll pass on that
45:24
So I think we've covered most of these
45:26
this idea of episodic versus serial
45:28
Think serial
45:30
in your mind as you think about your
45:31
brand
45:32
Outside versus inside. This last was a very
45:34
much of an inside negotiation
45:37
You'll have negotiations with third parties
45:40
and with people who are really close
45:42
whether they're employees, partners, brothers, sisters, children, spouses
45:47
The inside ones are by far the toughest
45:50
negotiations. They're the least forgiving
45:52
and they're the most important ones to lose
45:54
So this idea that every negotiation is a
45:56
competitive game that you have to win
45:59
it really helps you get over it
46:00
The more inside negotiations you do in your life
46:03
the more that you realize you don't have to win
46:05
certainly not every deal point
46:06
and you don't have to win every negotiation
46:09
So don't think of it as a competitive
46:10
game
46:11
This idea about select
46:13
I just like this quote
46:14
don't wrestle with pigs
46:15
you get dirty and they enjoy it
46:18
So be very careful who you negotiate with
46:20
And that means generating options
46:22
That means always having other people to talk with and to
46:25
to do business with
46:27
It is the worst thing in life is
46:29
to get in business with people that
46:31
don't have the same values you have
46:33
that you don't respect. I mean
46:35
it is misery. It's a
46:36
different kind of misery from
46:38
just about everything you know except being married
46:40
to somebody who makes you miserable
46:44
then this idea of being reputation building
46:47
I've given you my examples of that
46:49
but here are some
46:51
alternative reputations you have. One is I'm tough
46:54
I'm unbending, the legal documents govern
46:57
I've known a lot of people who are that way
46:59
and often they're people
47:00
who have a lot of money and a lot of la
47:03
Attorneys
47:04
and they really believe that's the smart way to do it
47:06
is guess what happens?
47:07
In the end, they may not have a lot of money
47:10
they may not have the same position of power
47:12
and they may not have a friend when
47:14
things go against them
47:17
live by the sword
47:18
die by the sword
47:19
You can be flexible
47:20
be re-open, open to reworking the
47:23
the
47:23
life company joint venture partner I told you
47:25
about who just said
47:26
take notes, Joel
47:28
Turns out he was one of the most
47:29
flexible partners you could ever have
47:32
So the documents were the documents were the
47:34
documents. He couldn't negotiate them
47:35
he didn't want you to negotiate
47:37
just take notes
47:38
But when it came to working out the
47:40
problems of living in the real world of doing business
47:45
he was extraordinarily flexible
47:47
And so I kept doing business with him
47:49
I probably did twenty-five deals with him
47:51
over my
47:52
life in real estate
47:53
because he was such a great partner
47:56
He was a tough negotiator
47:58
documenter, but he was a great partner
48:01
You can have this
48:03
reputation of being eager to make deals
48:06
where you just say
48:07
I do a lot of singles and doubles
48:09
I don't do home runs
48:09
The other is that people
48:12
there are some people in the negotiating world who just say
48:14
I only do home runs
48:15
If I don't get a four-bagger
48:17
if I don't hit a home run
48:18
if I don't win the thing
48:20
that's, those are the only deals I'll do
48:22
So you need to decide
48:23
what your reputation is there
48:26
We talked about these last couple
48:28
The, the last one is
48:30
this Fisher, Fisher and Urie
48:32
trained problem solver
48:34
and we'll talk for a second about Fisher and Urie
48:36
Yeah, comment. You're talking about
48:40
basically being selective about who you negotiate
48:43
What do you do when you're in a situation where
48:46
let's just say there is a vendor
48:49
That you need to negotiate with
48:51
And they are, you, you really need to think there's
48:52
there's not another alternative out there
48:57
You don't agree with their values
48:59
Yeah. What do you do in that kind
49:00
of situation? In some cases
49:01
you just have to suck it up and
49:02
negotiate with them. In some cases
49:04
you can get another party
49:06
in the organization you negotiate with
49:09
In other cases, you can talk to them and say
49:11
okay, here's where I think our conflict is coming
49:13
and get to a deeper level
49:15
and talk with them about it
49:16
I used to have a partner that would say
49:18
to people, you know
49:19
we're not making a deal on this
49:21
What would it take to make a deal?
49:23
And that was effective in certain circumstances
49:25
you know. What would it take
49:26
to get this relationship on a better
49:29
footing or to develop a
49:31
a more long-lasting give-take relationship?
49:33
I mean, sometimes you can get that real with people
49:37
My, my view is going back to the very beginning is
49:41
generate options. So you don't have one vendor
49:43
that you
49:44
really rely on or one alternative source of
49:46
financing or one. I mean
49:47
I like having a lot of options
49:50
So, and I
49:52
I realize that's a bit of a Pollyanna
49:55
You can't always do that
49:56
I mean, that
49:57
we just did a deal in one of
49:58
the companies I'm involved in where they
50:00
they were about forty percent of our business
50:04
They were really important. We
50:06
had to get that deal done
50:08
So consequently
50:09
we took notes and got the deal done
50:11
So you're gonna do some of that
50:12
There is not a panacea to every
50:15
negotiating problem. You are gonna deal with difficult
50:17
people. You're gonna have win-lose negotiations
50:20
You're gonna have some things that you dread
50:22
whatever. But I'm just saying you can nudge
50:23
it
50:24
So that it's a happier experience
50:26
It's a more of a win-win experience
50:28
And the better you choose parties
50:30
So here
50:31
here are
50:32
mindsets that I've got when I go into
50:34
negotiation. What time do we end
50:35
Marcella? Where'd Marcella go?
50:38
At twelve?
50:39
So we have till twelve
50:40
Are you happy until then
50:42
or
50:42
or people wanting to get out of here?
50:44
You're okay?
50:45
Well, let's talk a little bit about these
50:46
And one of the con
50:47
one of the mindsets that I think is
50:49
a really good mindset
50:51
is that a negotiation is just a conversation
50:55
It's just an exchange. You're good at conversations
50:58
You talk to people all the time
50:59
So this idea of
51:01
oh my gosh, we're going into a room
51:03
we're closing the doors
51:04
we're sitting on opposite sides of tables
51:07
you know
51:08
that feels a lot more threatening than
51:10
I'm just going to talk
51:12
about our various interests
51:14
and
51:14
try to have a conversation to come up
51:16
with something that's mutually satisfying
51:18
So think of negotiations as conversations
51:21
and you're good at it
51:22
Think of negotiations as a series we've mentioned
51:25
Think that agreements, winning
51:27
it's back to this idea of what is
51:29
winning
51:30
The idea
51:30
is that your agreement should be durable
51:34
There's no point
51:36
in coming to an agreement
51:37
that it terminates in a lawsuit
51:39
six months later
51:40
You've not negotiated a good agreement
51:43
So you want them to
51:44
there to be some elasticity
51:46
some sense
51:47
and usually that is a function
51:49
of how much trust
51:51
you've developed with your opposite party
51:53
If you've developed very high trust with your opposite party
51:57
once you come to an issue
51:58
the first instinct isn't
52:00
oh my gosh, let's go to the documents
52:01
What do the documents say?
52:03
Most of the good deals I've
52:04
ever made have never
52:06
once referred back to the documents
52:09
Not once
52:10
And some of these things have lasted twenty-five
52:12
thirty year, I mean, my whole business career
52:14
We never, ever once go to the documents
52:18
Why?
52:19
Because we like and trust each other
52:21
and these are real issues
52:22
and we sit down and we
52:23
talk it through. So you want a durable agreement
52:25
So that's, that's another mindset to have
52:28
Another mindset is this thinking win-win
52:31
Another one is to recognize that you're accountable to a
52:35
a lot of times people think as the negotiator
52:37
they're only accountable themselves. I'm winning for me
52:40
There are
52:41
very rare negotiations where you don't have broad
52:43
accountability
52:44
It's to your employees
52:46
it's to the community
52:47
it's to shareholders, it's to a board
52:50
Sometimes this can be a very effective
52:52
not-in-the-room party that you can use to give you
52:56
you some breathing room to pause and say
52:58
well, I can't
52:59
I wouldn't feel right about this
53:00
vis-a-vis the community. I don't really feel good
53:02
about dumping this sludge into the river
53:05
you know? I mean
53:06
you really have an accountability
53:07
So this idea that there's an accountability outside
53:09
your own interests
53:11
is a good mindset to have
53:13
Watching your language, I don't think it works to curse
53:19
scream, swear, slam doors, walk out of rooms
53:23
even bluff
53:24
I think bluffing is a fool's game
53:29
Because all you need to do is bluff
53:30
once and have it not happen
53:31
and you have spent your reputation
53:34
You are forevermore seen as a bluffer
53:36
So my
53:37
my view on that is just never bluff
53:40
Never use what I call high velocity words
53:43
Just
53:44
you think of the words that just sort
53:45
of raise people's emotional
53:48
tension and their temperature
53:49
just stay away from them
53:51
And if somebody uses them on you
53:53
ignore it. Don't let it work on you
53:55
Don't let your temperature rise
53:57
So watch your language and watch
54:02
Whether you are genuinely upset and you get frustrated
54:04
you know
54:05
you're not doing it for effect and you're
54:06
not using a technique that
54:08
you've tried to control it at all costs?
54:10
I, I think you should try to control it
54:12
and here's why
54:14
You know, if you
54:15
and if part of it is you're setting a baseline
54:18
you know, what, whatever your baseline is
54:19
it's the variation from your baseline that will
54:22
get effect
54:24
So if I say to you
54:26
I will never Agree to that
54:30
That's pretty powerful. If you know
54:32
if you've negotiated with me a lot of times
54:34
for me to say
54:35
I will never do that
54:36
I mean, you really believe
54:38
I just screamed that out
54:39
Whereas if I'm throwing things around and cursing and
54:43
you know, a lot of histrionics
54:45
I can shout, I'll never do that
54:47
And you'll say, yeah, yeah, yeah, okay
54:48
he'll come back tomorrow
54:49
So I think keeping the baseline
54:52
keeping the baseline really low is a very
54:54
smart
54:55
thing to do. Plus it keeps your own
54:56
blood pressure down
54:58
I did walk out of it
54:59
this billion dollar deal that I did out
55:01
here where we were swapping
55:02
a billion dollars worth of property
55:04
I sat with the partners in the room
55:05
There were six of them and one of me
55:07
and the most senior of them
55:10
just said something that was just completely
55:13
off the wall and unfair
55:14
And I just stood up and I said
55:17
gentlemen
55:18
it's been a pleasure to be
55:19
your partner all these years
55:20
I'm so sad
55:22
that it has to end this way
55:24
I am catching my plane
55:26
and I'll be Come on
55:27
give me a call in Dallas if you
55:28
want to talk about this
55:30
It was that simple. Before I could get to the airport
55:33
I had a call from three of these partners to say
55:36
please come back, we want to negotiate
55:38
And it wasn't that I'd
55:40
I, I had gotten up
55:41
I'd stood up when they said it
55:42
I'd left the room
55:43
but my speech was really that calm
55:46
And I think they took that as
55:47
oh my gosh, he is serious
55:50
He is really
55:52
serious. And that's the message
55:54
that I'm really serious
55:55
That's the one I wanted to get across
55:57
not that I'm chapped and I'm out of control or
56:00
because people don't trust that as much
56:03
In the end, this idea of being trusted
56:05
you know, if you really want to be an effective negotiator
56:09
be trusted. If the other party can trust you
56:12
over the long run
56:13
you'll develop that brand and you'll develop durable agreements
56:16
high trust relationships, creative solutions
56:20
Relationships with others that you like
56:23
et cetera. So I'm just recommending it as a
56:25
it's a different mindset than a lot of
56:27
people have towards it. Yeah
56:36
Yeah. It's kind of a universal language
56:47
Clarity
56:49
Over something in some cultures
56:51
it's just an absolute no-no
56:53
and you've lost and completely
56:54
burned all your credibility. You lose credibility
56:57
Yeah. You're seen as an unstable person
56:59
Or might or might not forgive you
57:00
Depending on the industry
57:02
Yeah
57:02
Some industries are full of wild people
57:07
Yeah
57:09
We negotiate through a
57:10
through an intermediary, an investment banker, an agent
57:13
or an attorney who's actually negotiating a
57:16
an agreement
57:18
Would, would you use this as a model for fine
57:22
for selecting an intermediary?
57:23
Because that person can often have a tremendous
57:25
impact on your brand as well
57:27
because they might act completely
57:29
and they're off on their own
57:30
you don't really know exactly what they're doing
57:32
either
57:32
I think you have to be
57:33
very careful in who you select
57:35
because they carry your brand
57:37
I've seen more attorneys
57:39
foul up deals than actually facilitate deals
57:42
In fact, I select my attorneys in terms of
57:45
are they deal facilitators?
57:46
Are they deal makers
57:48
problem solvers?
57:49
Or are they sort of egomaniacs who throw
57:51
who have to be right on every deal point
57:53
who have to draft the toughest document?
57:55
A lot of times what you'll do in
57:56
deals is you'll get attorneys fighting
57:59
and the attorneys will fight
58:00
and it'll destroy the deal and the relationship
58:03
So I
58:04
number one is I try not to have
58:06
very many intermediaries on the front line
58:08
I don't like to have agents
58:10
brokers, investment bankers, or attorneys negotiating my deals
58:15
I like to establish
58:16
a one-on-one relationship with the other principal
58:19
in deals. I really think that's the safest
58:21
way to maintain your brand
58:24
and it's the way to create
58:26
better relationships, to create better outcomes
58:28
It's more work in the short run
58:31
it's less work in the long run
58:35
I think
58:38
there is a reason that people use these intermediaries
58:41
and I think they can be valuable
58:42
and I think it's always smart to have
58:44
somebody outside the room
58:46
Because negotiations are these real-time
58:49
things where you're exchanging things back and forth
58:51
back and forth, back and forth, and you can make mistakes
58:53
and it really helps to have somebody
58:55
whether it's a board
58:56
a partner, an attorney or whatever
58:58
who can come in
58:59
refine, correct, smooth over
59:01
So I like to use them in all those things
59:03
and a lot of times I'll say
59:04
I need to run this by my partners
59:06
or I'll need to
59:07
I'd be, this makes sense to me
59:09
but let me check with the attorney or
59:10
tax counsel or my accountant on this
59:12
So, you know
59:13
I like to have a little bit of a background
59:15
so I use them that way
59:16
but I never put them and say
59:18
my attorney will negotiate with your attorney and
59:20
make a deal
59:21
I think it's very dangerous
59:23
It's not to say it doesn't work
59:24
yeah. I have a question regarding this idea of
59:28
just not, not really going above or below this
59:32
median
59:33
And as someone, I'm, I'm very emotive, that's who I am
59:37
and what, what I'm hearing is
59:39
you know, poker face
59:40
try not to get hooked into these things
59:42
try not to be emotional
59:43
Which to me is really like
59:45
if you said
59:46
the best way to negotiate is if you're six foot tall
59:48
and I'm five feet tall
59:49
So that, to me it's like
59:51
okay, that, I, I agree
59:53
I can see how that would be effective
59:55
How do you... But you're just not six feet tall
59:57
Yeah, I'm, I'm not six feet tall
59:59
so how, how do I
59:59
And I think you start out by being
60:01
yourself
60:01
Authenticity is something that will be measured by the opposing party
60:06
which
60:06
which will go back to trust a lot
60:08
I'm just saying that the
60:10
the, you can modulate, you can
60:13
you can keep the swings from being so wild
60:17
and, and that will help you
60:19
You know, it won't make you six feet tall
60:21
but it may make you five foot two
60:24
I, I think you need to be yourself
60:26
I mean, I'm demonstrative, too
60:28
I mean, I speak with my hands
60:29
I wander around, I get
60:31
I get excited about ideas
60:32
I mean, it's who I am
60:34
So I be, I am that
60:36
but I just say there are certain things
60:38
there are certain
60:38
certain thresholds that I don't want to cross
60:40
because I spend a lot
60:43
if I cross those thresholds
60:44
I've spent something
60:45
that doesn't return to me what it's worth
60:47
So if you're all over the map and around like that
60:49
you just need to realize you're spending something
60:51
that's pretty valuable
60:53
And, and you don't have any place to go
60:55
You know, once you've cranked the volume up all the way
60:57
there's no place to go
60:58
So leave yourself a place to go
61:00
And I, I think moderating
61:01
And the final one is
61:03
be likable. And I know this is
61:05
I mean
61:06
you didn't come to Stanford to hear be likable
61:10
but I, when I went through litigation
61:12
I remember
61:15
talking with
61:16
I think it was opposing counsel
61:18
after it was all over again
61:20
And, he said something like
61:23
you know, I wanted to dislike
61:25
I wanted to hate you
61:26
I really wanted to be as angry at you as
61:30
the plaintiff was
61:33
He said
61:34
but I couldn't help
61:36
but kind of liking you
61:38
And he said, and it influenced, he said
61:39
I didn't want it influencing
61:40
I'm a professional, and I did my job
61:42
but it still had an impact
61:44
So I talked to my attorney about it
61:46
and he says, you know
61:46
I've had the same experience where I've gone
61:48
and he'd, he'd, depose Ivan Boesky, he'd, I mean
61:52
you go down the list of people
61:53
he'd been through a whole bunch of them
61:55
and he said, you know
61:56
certain of them were really likable scoundrels
61:59
and it made a difference
62:00
And others, you know
62:01
you just wanted to fry
62:04
And so this idea
62:05
there is something in all
62:06
even the most jaded
62:08
professionally trained litigator who does gladiating for
62:13
for a life, you know
62:14
says it makes a difference
62:16
if you like the other party
62:18
So I think there is almost no
62:20
upside in being a jerk
62:22
in being a turkey. I just don't think
62:24
it gets you anywhere
62:25
Well, we're about out of time
62:26
I, well
62:27
let's just see if we've got any more
62:28
of these
62:30
We've talked about agents
62:32
being a principal, we talked about lawyers as memorializers or agents
62:38
disputes
62:43
you know, this is in the far end
62:45
the formal end of negotiation
62:47
whether you mediate, arbitrate, or litigate
62:51
I guess my advice
62:52
on that is they're all kind of bad outcomes
62:56
and you really want to avoi- you really want durable
62:59
flexible agreements and trust relationships
63:02
If you have to get to these
63:04
litigation
63:05
and arbitration are not
63:06
that different in terms of
63:09
arbitration may be a little shorter and a little less expensive
63:12
but you're still presenting information under rules of evidence
63:16
typically to a
63:18
special master
63:19
or a rented judge or some-
63:21
so it's a very much the same kind of thing
63:23
Mediation
63:24
that negotiation is a split the baby negotiation
63:27
So if you're right
63:29
you're gonna lose half
63:32
so I think you
63:33
you just want to be
63:34
so this is again in this very style
63:36
stylized
63:37
formalized way. The rules of those negotiations
63:40
very much narrow your outcomes
63:43
so just to be aware
63:45
Implementing the agreement, fleshing out hidden agenda items
63:48
outbursts of material that
63:50
that we've kind of talked about all of those
63:52
I think
63:53
so Fisher and Urey. Has everybody in here read
63:58
how many have read
63:59
Getting to Yes?
64:02
Only a few of you
64:03
It may be so old that people don't
64:05
read it. It's still the classic book
64:07
on negotiation. I would recommend it to all
64:09
of you
64:09
who want to become a better negotiator
64:11
Written in 1981 by
64:14
Fisher and Urey, two Harvard lawyers, and
64:17
they talk about their negotiation in the salt
64:19
talks
64:20
and a lot of data on really sort
64:22
of what works and what doesn't
64:23
They wrote another book called Getting Past No
64:26
So getting to yes is the first one
64:28
getting past no is the second one
64:30
Actually, the second one, though much less read
64:32
In fact
64:33
is there anybody in here that's read getting past?
64:35
Okay, great
64:36
Not very many people have read it
64:38
It's actually, I think, even a better
64:39
more insightful book if you've done a lot
64:41
of negotiating
64:42
Those are two really sort of good
64:44
practical academic
64:46
texts that give you a good map
64:48
And I can usually tell when I'm negotiating
64:50
with somebody who has studied Urey and Fisher
64:52
It's a different kind of a negotiation
64:54
It's actually quite pleasant
64:57
so here's the
64:58
If you don't want to read it
64:59
here's the Reader's Digest version
65:02
saving you time
65:03
You thought you were
65:04
wasting an hour with me?
65:06
I'm going to save you a couple of hours
65:08
Basically, the idea is separate the peo
65:10
So here are the four fundamentals
65:12
Separate the people from the problem
65:14
which a lot of people don't do
65:15
They merge them
65:16
You know, the problem's thorny
65:17
therefore I don't like the people
65:19
The people who have this issue that is brought before me
65:23
because I don't like the issue or it's
65:24
putting me in an awkward position
65:26
I also don't like those people
65:28
You know, so a lot of confusion
65:29
So they say separate those two
65:31
then focus on interests
65:32
not position. In other words
65:34
what would you like to see happen?
65:35
Not what position are you going to take
65:37
or is the other party going to take?
65:39
Because positions are not necessarily
65:41
related to what are really in your interest
65:43
People express positions
65:45
that may not be the actual
65:47
endpoint that reflects their interest
65:49
Then invent options together for mutual gain
65:52
where you think outside the box
65:54
you invent options, and then insist, if you can
65:58
this is the hardest one for me
66:00
is figuring out objective criteria
66:02
You know, what
66:03
what would be a winning deal?
66:04
What would work?
66:05
And then
66:06
assess your deal against these objective criteria
66:09
That is the hardest one for me
66:10
but it, I, I've seen it work
66:12
And then finally for me
66:13
I'd say know your BATNA
66:15
Figure it out, write it out, know it going in
66:18
and my corollary to that is
66:20
calculate the other party's BATNA
66:22
So you really know that it's not life
66:23
or death. There are alternatives
66:25
and you'll be more likely to have successful negotiations
66:31
now, I'm gonna show you there
66:33
these are the, again, more Fisher and Urey things
66:35
but, if you'll just
66:38
this is how they deal with some of
66:39
these dealing with problems and framing things
66:41
So I'm gonna flash
66:42
this slide up and one other slide up
66:45
and then have you think about
66:46
what else this relates to
66:48
You know, discuss each other, don't blame the opponent
66:51
see the opponent's intentions
66:53
see the situation
66:55
you know, from their perspective
66:57
give the mistake and the outcome
67:01
You know, don't react to provocation
67:03
Step away. Don't respond reflexively
67:05
Be an active listener
67:07
Agree when you can
67:08
I used to have a friend that I negotiated
67:10
a guy that became a friend that I negotiated with
67:12
who'd start out every negotiation with all of
67:14
the things we agreed on
67:16
So that you'd go through ten items
67:18
You'd say, okay, we agree on this
67:20
we agree on that
67:21
And you got in this reflexive habit of just agreeing
67:23
Okay, I agree to that
67:24
That works. I agree to that
67:26
That works. Okay, that's good
67:28
And you'd get down to
67:29
then number eleven and twelve and thirteen
67:31
which were the tough ones
67:33
So, these are things that Yuri and Fisher
67:37
discussed. Now what it
67:39
you know, I
67:39
I guess I'll just tell you because we're
67:41
out of time
67:42
My take on this is
67:43
this is marriage. You know
67:46
this is how
67:48
I've made a marriage work for thirty-five years
67:50
Is basically doing these things
67:53
and
67:53
and most of the relationships you're in
67:56
are subject to negotiation
67:58
If you kind of listen to these best practices
68:01
your life will work better
68:02
your relationships will work better
68:04
and your conversations will be happier
68:06
your agreements will be more durable
68:09
and
68:09
most of the time you'll feel like you
68:12
won
68:12
Most of the time you won't feel dirty
68:14
like you need to take a shower
68:17
and negotiations won't be just eating your broccoli
68:21
but it will be something that gives you life
68:23
that lets you express creativity
68:25
and build relationships
68:27
So
68:29
I'll hang around here after if any of
68:30
you want to discuss this or have any questions
68:32
but thank you very much
68:33
Thank you

Watch these videos on your TV

XTTV brings video content from X to your living room. Download now and start watching on the big screen.