← Back to videos

This guy literally explained why some people become successful… while others stay average. And th

Ram Singh Verma

Ram Singh Verma

@RamSingh_369

November 18, 2026· 53:33

This guy literally explained why some people become successful… while others stay average. And the reason is uncomfortable. It’s not just hard work. It’s not luck. It’s Game Theory. Once you understand this, you’ll start seeing the “game” behind success differently. Watch this. 👀

Transcript

0:01
Today we look at the question of success
0:03
okay? The question is
0:06
who succeeds and why?
0:10
Okay, so we, we've done a lot of research
0:16
and we discovered that people who succeed
0:21
succeed for certain reasons
0:24
So, there is a Columbia psychologist named Walter Mitchell
0:32
and he devised a very
0:33
famous experiment called the marshmallow test
0:41
In the marshmallow test
0:42
it's very, very easy, okay?
0:44
So imagine a room
0:46
and I invite a four-year-old or a five-year-old
0:48
to come into this room
0:50
and I have a conversation with him or her
0:53
I ask them, how's your mother
0:55
what do you like to do
0:56
and it's a very good conversation
0:58
Then suddenly I get up and say
1:01
I'm really sorry
1:03
but I need to go across the hallway for another meeting
1:06
but I'll be back
1:08
okay?
1:08
So just wait for me
1:10
And here, and here
1:10
I'll make you a deal
1:12
Here's a marshmallow
1:13
I'm going to put a marshmallow in front of you
1:17
and you can have it right now
1:19
but if I come back and the marshmallow is still there
1:22
I will give you two marshmallows
1:25
okay?
1:26
And
1:27
and then, Walter Mitchell, he goes away
1:30
and he goes behind the room
1:33
and for a see-through mirror
1:35
he's able to see the students
1:37
as they struggle to contain themselves
1:39
because obviously they want two marshmallows
1:41
And there are some students who can
1:43
in fact
1:45
resist the temptation to eat the first marshmallow
1:47
and then the second marshmallow
1:48
but then there are others who cannot
1:51
And Walter Mitchell will spend fifty years just tracking them
1:54
okay?
1:55
What he discovers is this
1:57
The students who resist the temptation
2:02
who get the second marshmallow
2:03
they are much more likely to do better
2:05
in school
2:06
They have higher test scores
2:08
They have
2:09
better careers. Their careers are more stable
2:11
They get promoted in their careers
2:13
They're much more able
2:15
to find a stable relationship
2:18
they avoid jail. They avoid drugs
2:20
They avoid alcohol. They're more lean
2:21
They're more fit
2:23
They live longer
2:25
Better teeth
2:26
And those who cannot resist
2:31
and eat the first marshmallow right away
2:33
they have the opposite effect
2:35
okay?
2:36
And so the idea is that for Walter Mitchell
2:39
success means delayed
2:46
gratification
2:50
And all this means is that
2:52
people who succeed are capable of long-term planning
2:59
To succeed today, I will make sacrifices necessary
3:04
okay?
3:05
So, so if my friends are playing outside
3:08
and I need to do my homework
3:10
well, I'm going to stay home and do my homework
3:12
Okay, so long-term planning
3:13
what he calls delayed gratification
3:16
Or a much more simple way
3:18
way of saying this is the idea of self-control
3:22
right?
3:23
Or the idea of emotional
3:27
regulation
3:29
You're able to keep your emotions in check
3:35
If you're angry, you're able to calm yourself down
3:39
Okay, and so we've tried
3:41
we know about this
3:42
and that's why in school
3:43
we focus on the idea of emotion regulation
3:46
teaching you how to better control your emotions
3:49
how to do long-term planning
3:51
okay?
3:53
So that's one theory of success
3:57
Another theory of success
3:58
comes to us from another psychologist named Carol Dwight
4:03
and she's at Stanford
4:06
And she wrote a book called Mindset
4:12
Okay?
4:12
And what she tells us is that
4:15
those who succeed in life have a growth mindset
4:22
and those who fail in life have a
4:23
fixed mindset
4:27
Okay?
4:28
And it's not hard
4:30
okay? The idea is resilience
4:36
Those of a growth mindset
4:38
if they fall or they fail
4:40
they see themselves
4:41
this opportunity for me to learn
4:44
So I'm going to think about what I did wrong
4:47
next time I'll do better
4:49
And the fixed mindset are people
4:52
who cannot accept the idea of failure
4:54
who think that it's because they're not capable of improving
5:00
and therefore they give up
5:03
Okay?
5:04
So those of a growth mindset
5:07
if they fail, they try harder
5:08
Those of a fixed mindset
5:10
if they fail, they just give up
5:14
And so the idea of resilience
5:15
okay? Pretty simple, right?
5:18
And the third
5:19
idea of success comes to us from K
5:22
Anders Ericsson, who is a Swedish psychologist
5:26
and she wants to know why
5:28
certain people
5:29
are able to succeed as musicians or athletes
5:33
And he creates the idea of deliberate practice
5:44
Okay?
5:44
So what he found is that
5:46
people who want to become athletes or musicians
5:50
they work really hard
5:51
they practice every day
5:53
But the people who succeed practice strategically
5:58
okay?
5:59
So those who, work hard just work a long time
6:04
but those who work strategically have a plan
6:08
The plan is this
6:10
What are my goals?
6:13
How can I achieve these goals?
6:17
And then how do I improve my plan?
6:24
Okay?
6:24
So they're examining their own practices
6:29
And they're trying to figure out where the weaknesses are
6:32
where they can improve
6:33
they set a plan on how to improve
6:37
and then they follow this plan
6:39
And if this plan helps them improve
6:41
they stick to the plan
6:42
but if the plan doesn't really work
6:45
they change the plan as well
6:46
okay? So this is the idea of self-reflection
6:54
or self-assessment
7:00
Constantly thinking about how you are as a student
7:05
and figure out
7:06
figure out how to improve your own
7:09
learning strategies
7:10
And what Kenneth Erickson discovered is that if you do this
7:14
you'll succeed at anything
7:16
And this is true
7:17
okay? And the
7:18
the reason why we know it's true is
7:20
there are two American psychologists named Dunning
7:22
Dunning and Kruger
7:25
There's something, the Dunning-Kruger effect
7:30
And so what they did was this
7:31
they ran an experiment
7:32
They had 500 students in a psychology class
7:34
first year university
7:36
They made every student take an IQ test
7:40
And then after they took the IQ test
7:43
they asked each student
7:45
how do you think you did on the
7:46
IQ test?
7:47
Do you place in the top 5%
7:50
or the bottom 5%?
7:52
And it turns out that no one got the ranking correct
7:59
okay? So those who were in the top 5%
8:02
in terms of IQ
8:04
thought they were maybe in the top 20%
8:06
Because for them it was easy
8:08
so they assumed everyone
8:10
for everyone else it was easy as well
8:13
But what was
8:14
dramatic is that
8:16
those who scored the lowest thought they were average
8:19
okay? So the
8:20
worst 5% in the class
8:23
thought they were in the top 50% or
8:25
just average
8:27
And the reason, and the reason why is
8:29
those people who are stupid
8:31
lack the capacity to know they're stupid
8:35
Okay?
8:35
So what Dunning-Kruger discovered is that
8:37
the hardest part of being a student
8:41
is to assess yourself properly
8:44
to know exactly where you stand and how
8:47
to improve
8:48
Those who are stupid
8:49
are often the most confident in the world
8:53
That's what's called the Dunning-Kruger effect
8:55
and this
8:56
this helps explain why the world is
8:59
why it is. Because often the people in power are stupid
9:01
they don't know they're stupid
9:03
they were confident, and they do stupid things
9:05
like Donald Trump, okay?
9:07
All right?
9:09
All right, so now with these three theories
9:11
right, we have self-control, we have resilience
9:14
and we have self-assessment
9:16
And which, and so as educators
9:19
as schools, what we can do is devise strategies In curriculum
9:25
top students all succeed
9:27
correct, right?
9:29
The problem is that when we actually try this
9:33
it doesn't work, okay?
9:36
If you take a bad student and you teach him self-control
9:40
resilience, and self-assessment
9:44
the student doesn't actually get better
9:47
The reason why is
9:49
okay
9:49
and this is a very important
9:50
idea for you guys to remember
9:52
is that correlation
9:57
does not equal causation
10:03
okay? You guys need to remember this
10:06
Just because things are correlated
10:07
does not mean they cause each other
10:10
So I'll give you an example
10:11
We know that successful people
10:14
they get up early in the morning
10:16
okay? They get up at four o'clock in
10:17
the morning
10:18
But
10:19
just because you get up at four o'clock
10:20
in the morning does not mean you'll succeed
10:23
Okay?
10:25
Just because you work hard
10:26
just because you're resilient
10:29
just because you have growth mindset
10:31
does not mean you'll succeed
10:34
But if you're successful
10:36
you'll get up early in the morning because
10:37
you're mo- you are more motivated
10:41
If you are successful in life
10:43
you will have more con- self-control
10:46
You will have, more resilience
10:49
You will, you'll be more humble
10:52
Okay? Does that make sense?
10:53
So if you're rich
10:55
guess what happens?
10:56
You become successful
10:59
And therefore, you will have growth mindset
11:05
self-control, deliberate practice
11:08
Okay, does that make sense?
11:11
But just because you have growth mindset
11:12
deliberate practice, and resilience
11:16
does not mean you'll succeed
11:19
Okay?
11:20
So the question for us is
11:23
why does this happen?
11:25
And ultimately, who succeeds?
11:28
Okay
11:29
so we know for a fact that
11:31
rich people are much more likely
11:33
likely to succeed than poor people
11:38
And in fact
11:38
what we know from
11:41
macroeconomic studies is that school doesn't really matter
11:45
Doesn't matter how well you do in school
11:47
If your parents are rich
11:48
you'll be successful in life
11:49
If your parents are poor
11:50
you will not be successful in life
11:52
okay?
11:53
So what's the difference? Okay
11:54
so now let's look at parenting strategies between rich and poor
12:03
okay?
12:05
So there are lots of differences
12:07
but let's focus on three major differences
12:11
The first major difference is that
12:16
rich parents Speak to the kids more
12:22
than poor parents
12:25
Okay? High vocabulary, low vocabulary
12:32
When rich parents speak to the kids
12:34
rich parents will use high vocabulary
12:37
longer sentences
12:41
Poor parents will just be no
12:44
yes, go away
12:46
Okay?
12:47
Another major difference is in attitude
12:55
Okay?
12:55
So rich parents use a friendly attitude
13:00
and poor parents use an authoritarian
13:04
or command attitude
13:08
So for example
13:10
If you are a rich kid
13:13
and you go and touch a stove
13:17
okay, and you burn your hand
13:20
the rich parent will say
13:22
listen, you made a mistake
13:23
don't worry about it
13:24
let me explain to you why
13:26
touching a fire is bad for you
13:28
because you'll burn yourself
13:31
and
13:32
you might have to go to a doctor
13:34
and we will feel pain if you hurt yourself
13:38
okay? So the rich parent
13:39
will spend a lot of time explaining to
13:40
the child
13:41
why this is wrong and how not to
13:43
do it again
13:45
The poor parent is like
13:46
don't you ever do that again or I'll
13:48
beat the crap out of you
13:50
okay?
13:51
Don't do that
13:52
Pretty simple, okay?
13:54
But as you can understand
13:56
the
13:57
rich kid
13:58
will understand that the world is safe
14:01
and that he is respected in this world
14:05
okay?
14:07
Whereas the poor child will think that the world is scary
14:10
and he
14:11
or she must be afraid of adults
14:14
And this carries on into school
14:15
right?
14:16
Because as a rich kid
14:17
you go to school
14:19
and you think that
14:20
oh, my teacher is my friend
14:22
So you smile at the teacher
14:24
and you hug the teacher
14:25
and the teacher smiles back
14:26
and now you're friends
14:27
right?
14:28
But if you're a poor kid
14:29
and you see the teacher
14:31
you don't
14:32
you're afraid to look at the teacher
14:34
You don't smile. You're
14:36
you are stressed, okay?
14:38
And the teacher thinks that you might be
14:40
a problem child
14:41
So the problem with this is that
14:44
yes, being a third-term parent
14:46
it is effective, but it creates stress in the family
14:52
okay? It makes the child feel unsafe
14:55
And this leads to our
14:56
the third major difference
14:58
between rich parents and poor parents
15:01
Rich parents offer stability
15:05
Okay?
15:06
Poor parents can only offer volatility
15:11
This is a very simple idea
15:12
Rich parents have money
15:14
so they can afford to keep promises
15:17
So I'm, rich parent, I say to my child
15:20
okay
15:21
next week we'll go to Thailand for vacation
15:23
Guess what? Next week you go
15:24
you guys go to Thailand for vacation
15:27
But if you're a poor parent
15:29
money is always an issue
15:30
so it's hard for you to keep promises
15:32
right? So it's like
15:33
next week we'll, we'll go to McDonald's for lunch
15:35
but your paycheck, is not enough, so you're like, sorry
15:40
we can't go anymore
15:42
Okay?
15:44
And now, because of these different parenting styles
15:47
we understand why
15:51
rich kids behave different from poor kids
15:53
right? So let's look at
15:55
let's look at the idea
15:56
idea of self-control, right? Self-control
16:04
What is the marshmallow test?
16:05
Marshmallow test is not a test of self-control
16:09
it's a test of your trust in others
16:13
right?
16:14
If you believe that the teacher who goes outside
16:19
if you believe that he or she comes back and will
16:23
and will keep his or her promise
16:25
then you will not eat that marshmallow
16:28
But if you think that this teacher is lying to me
16:31
then you're not going to eat that marshmallow
16:33
Then you will eat that marshmallow
16:34
right?
16:35
So it's not really about self-control
16:36
it's about your belief and trust in authority figures
16:40
right? So if you're rich
16:42
stability, you have stability, but if you're poor
16:44
you don't have stability
16:45
so you're actually better off eating that marshmallow
16:48
rather than waiting for that second marshmallow
16:50
because guess what? Most of the time
16:53
you will not get that second marshmallow
16:55
Okay, do you understand?
16:57
So it's not that poor kids are stupid
16:59
poor kids are rational
17:01
and they're responding to
17:03
the circumstances that they live in
17:07
Okay?
17:09
And resilience, right?
17:12
Well
17:12
the idea of resilience is that
17:15
you believe that the world will help you
17:19
right? So if you're rich
17:23
and you believe that everyone helps you
17:24
you can be resilient
17:26
because If you fail
17:29
someone will help you get up
17:31
If you're poor, if you fail, that probably tells you
17:35
you shouldn't be doing this
17:38
Okay?
17:39
You probably won't succeed doing this
17:41
So you don't have
17:42
you don't have much confidence in others
17:45
Okay? And the idea of self-assessment
17:48
right?
17:49
Looking inward
17:53
Well
17:53
if you're a poor child
17:55
who lives under a lot of stress
17:57
it's hard for you to be self-reflective
18:00
because if you look back at yourself
18:01
all you can think about is your pain
18:03
and your stress
18:06
Okay?
18:08
So from these different parenting strategies
18:11
we can now explain why
18:14
different students behave the way they do
18:17
This, of course, May lead you to think
18:20
okay, well then, rather than construct our schools around self-control
18:25
resilience, and, self-reflection
18:30
we should construct our schools around better parenting skills
18:34
okay? Which means that
18:35
hey
18:36
let's construct schools where kids are exposed to
18:39
a lot of vocabulary
18:41
where teachers are friendly
18:43
and where there's a lot of stability
18:45
okay?
18:47
And we've tried this
18:49
and it's more effective
18:51
but it doesn't really work either
18:55
Why? Because the kids come in too late
18:57
A lot of their worldview is already established
19:00
Then you're like, okay
19:01
well then let's change how parents behave
19:04
And when you do that
19:05
what you recognize is that
19:07
nope, you can't change how they behave either
19:11
okay?
19:13
So no matter what you do
19:15
you end up
19:16
with
19:17
massive differences between the poor and the rich
19:21
The rich stay rich
19:23
and the poor stay poor
19:25
Okay, so now the question for us is
19:31
why is this the case?
19:34
Okay?
19:35
And it's the case because
19:38
society is a hierarchy
19:47
Okay? And the hierarchy
19:48
is usually divided between
19:49
the rich and the poor
19:51
Okay?
20:00
And these two worlds are night and day
20:03
They're very, very different
20:05
As a poor person
20:07
if you want to survive
20:08
you have to obey authority
20:16
Okay?
20:17
But if you're a rich person
20:18
the way that you get along with others
20:20
the way that you maximize
20:23
your outcome is by negotiating with others
20:26
okay?
20:27
Negotiating
20:33
Okay? So negotiating can also mean debate
20:36
right?
20:37
So who should be the boss?
20:38
Well, let's have a debate and present different evidence as to
20:43
should figure out who's
20:44
who should be the boss
20:46
Okay? So negotiation means debate and argument
20:52
So this helps us
20:54
this helps us understand why different parents
20:58
Parent their child differently
21:00
If you're a poor parent
21:02
your responsibility
21:03
is to make sure that your child
21:05
knows how to obey authority
21:08
okay? That's why you command your child
21:13
But if you are a rich parent
21:15
you want your child to be able to negotiate with authority
21:19
and that's why you respect your child
21:22
and you teach your child how to debate
21:25
how to argue, how to negotiate with others
21:30
okay?
21:32
Because they live in different worlds
21:38
Another way of saying this is that from day one
21:44
rich kids know that they're playing a different game than
21:49
they're playing a different game from poor kids
21:52
okay?
21:53
So
21:56
Let's go back and look at parents
22:00
Okay?
22:02
So
22:06
poor parents command their child
22:11
don't really speak, don't communicate
22:17
and don't keep promises
22:19
okay?
22:25
All right
22:26
so poor parents do these three things
22:29
And we know that if they do these three things
22:32
the outcome won't be so good
22:33
okay?
22:34
And the reason why
22:35
they do this is that
22:37
they're not playing a game to improve their kid's outcome
22:41
they're playing a game to get along with other parents
22:44
okay?
22:47
Okay, colleagues
22:52
family
22:56
Okay, authority. Okay, so another saying this is this
23:03
police, boss, okay, family, okay?
23:08
All right, so as a parent
23:10
you're trying to figure out how
23:11
how to negotiate with the police
23:15
with your boss, and with your family
23:19
So if you're a poor person
23:21
and the police knows you're a poor person
23:24
the police is going to bully you
23:26
And if you fight back
23:27
the police will probably put you in jail
23:31
Okay? So it's very important that you accept authority
23:36
you don't challenge authority
23:37
because if you do
23:38
you're probably going into trouble
23:41
Your boss, right?
23:42
If you're a poor person
23:44
your, your boss will just command you about
23:47
And so it's very important that your child
23:49
knows how to take orders
23:51
Rather than ask questions
23:53
rather than debate
23:55
your child must learn how to just follow orders
23:58
or at least keep his mouth shut
23:59
okay?
24:01
And then family
24:03
is about maintaining good relations with
24:07
those who can most support you
24:09
and that often means the same values
24:16
Okay? So if the
24:18
if your family members or your friends
24:19
if they are
24:21
if they are parenting their child in this manner
24:24
you're also gonna copy them
24:25
okay? Imitation
24:29
Right?
24:30
And for a poor person
24:32
this is the optimal strategy
24:36
of how to parent
24:44
Okay?
24:45
Does that make sense
24:45
guys?
24:47
Because if you do it another way
24:49
okay, if you are, if you choose to
24:53
be a friend to your child
24:56
if you choose to communicate
24:58
if you choose to keep your promises
25:01
then the
25:04
your friends and your family will think that
25:06
you're doing something wrong
25:08
You understand?
25:09
They, they won't think, oh my god
25:11
you are an enlightened
25:12
parent who's read a lot of parenting books
25:15
and great for you
25:16
They're gonna think there's something wrong with you
25:20
okay?
25:21
So let
25:21
let me give you an example of this
25:24
Let me give you an example of this
25:27
So, my wife and I have three kids
25:30
okay?
25:32
My parenting style
25:36
So my wife and I have three kids
25:38
and this is how we parent our kid
25:40
okay? First of all
25:42
we Have our child
25:45
we give our child a lot of freedom
25:47
So, so we don't have our kids do activities
25:50
okay?
25:51
We don't have our kids do lots
25:52
lots of, lots of activities
25:56
We don't send our kids to math class
25:57
we don't send our kids to swimming class
25:59
we don't send our kids to piano class
26:01
okay? We just let our kids
26:02
run around and play
26:05
The other thing that we do
26:06
is we communicate a lot with our child
26:11
Communication, we believe in democracy in our
26:13
in our family
26:15
If there's, if we're going to make a decision together
26:18
we want everyone to communicate together
26:21
okay?
26:24
so
26:29
a normal Chinese family will just have a very tight schedule
26:31
right?
26:32
And the other thing that we do that's
26:33
different is we tell stories
26:36
The other Chinese families will do math
26:39
okay?
26:41
So
26:42
we
26:42
raise our children in a
26:44
way that's very different from normal Chinese families
26:49
from the way that you've been raised
26:51
okay? And we do this because both my wife and I
26:55
we spend a lot of time
26:56
talking about parenting
26:58
I've read a lot of books about parenting
27:01
I've spent many decades researching the best education
27:04
possible
27:05
And so that's why we
27:07
raise our children in this way
27:10
And guess what?
27:11
Because we do this
27:13
we have no friends in China
27:16
We have family, but they all think we're crazy
27:19
okay?
27:22
But we do this because for us
27:24
what's most important is to make sure
27:27
that our children are happy and healthy
27:30
and that they have a chance to
27:32
be creative and be successful in life
27:35
Because I think that if you do it this way
27:37
the child will not be creative
27:38
will not be successful
27:40
But if you do it this way
27:42
your child will fit in into China better
27:48
Okay?
27:49
So, parenting, the goal, the incentive
27:55
is not for your child to succeed
27:58
it's, the incentive is for your child to fit into China
28:03
or the
28:04
larger social environment that you are in
28:07
Okay?
28:09
And that's why
28:10
it's very hard to change the way
28:13
people behave
28:15
And that's why social structures are extremely rigid
28:20
because
28:21
the game they're playing
28:22
is often just to fit into their environment
28:26
Hey, does that make sense
28:27
guys?
28:28
Okay, any questions before I move on?
28:31
yep
28:35
Thanks. so, so for poor families
28:38
is there any way for the poor kids to be succeed
28:42
to be the
28:42
the rich parent you described in the future?
28:46
Yeah
28:48
Okay, that's, that's a really good question
28:51
okay?
28:52
so
28:53
we know that there are certain poor kids
28:55
who do succeed. For example
28:57
I'm a poor kid who succeeded
28:59
My, we immigrated to Toronto
29:02
Canada, when I was like six years old
29:04
and my father was a dishwasher
29:06
so we were a very poor family
29:08
okay?
29:09
And
29:10
but I succeeded
29:11
because I left Canada for the United States
29:15
So Canada is a very rich place
29:17
where poor people basically move up a bit
29:20
but not too far
29:22
But
29:23
I was able to succeed because
29:25
I was able to
29:27
get a scholarship to go study in the United States
29:30
Okay, so there are opportunities
29:32
The problem, though, is that it means leaving your community
29:38
Okay, does that make sense?
29:40
So one way to succeed is to abandon your community
29:48
Okay, but that's high risk
29:53
right?
29:55
So you have to be extremely individualistic
29:58
to take such a risk
30:03
So that's why most people don't do it
30:05
Because if you think about it
30:07
the safest option for you is to stay
30:09
within your community
30:11
That's what's going to guarantee you the most
30:15
the best outcome
30:16
But you choose to abandon your community and to say
30:19
and to say, you know what
30:19
I'm going to go somewhere else and try my
30:21
try my luck
30:21
That's taking a really high risk
30:23
okay?
30:24
So you choose to succeed
30:26
you have to take high risk
30:27
So another possibility is war
30:33
that traditionally, historically, has been
30:39
the best mechanism of social mobility
30:41
When you
30:42
when you go fight a war and you do really well
30:46
you get promoted in life
30:48
okay?
30:50
But again
30:51
war is high risk because chances are you get killed
30:55
okay? So not just war
30:56
but also revolution, right?
31:01
Okay?
31:02
And of course
31:04
the best way, of course, is to marry up
31:06
marrying up
31:11
Okay, and that's why, remember, remember, in our very first class
31:15
we talked about the dating game
31:16
right?
31:17
Where women
31:22
only want five and four
31:24
okay? The reason why is that
31:26
five and four are high status
31:30
and three, two, one are low status
31:33
So if you're a woman
31:34
you don't want to marry into a low
31:35
status family because your children will be screwed over
31:39
okay? Your best option is to take a risk
31:43
gamble into a high status
31:46
and marry, you want
31:47
you want to try to marry into a
31:48
high status family
31:50
Okay, so traditionally
31:53
war and marrying up are the
31:57
two major mechanisms of social mobility
31:59
In today's world
32:04
abandoning community can also lead to success
32:08
Okay, basically immigrating to a place that offers more social mobility
32:13
which often means United States
32:15
Okay, but another way of saying this is
32:18
you have to get really lucky
32:19
guys
32:22
Okay, so there's lots of poor people who think that
32:24
you know
32:24
I succeeded because I worked hard and I'm really talented
32:27
Look, I was born poor
32:30
I lucked into Yale
32:32
okay, it's luck
32:35
You can work as hard as you want
32:37
but the chances are against you
32:41
Okay, and it takes a certain personality
32:43
which is you're really individualistic
32:45
you're very ambitious
32:46
and you have high risk tolerance
32:49
Most people don't have that
32:50
okay
32:51
So yes, there are certain people who
32:54
despite their background, they're able to succeed
32:57
but that's often the exception to the rule
33:00
as opposed to the rule itself
33:01
Okay, so thank you
33:03
Is this clear?
33:04
Okay, any more questions, guys
33:05
before I move on?
33:08
Okay
33:14
Can be luck
33:16
counted as a kind of ability or it's just coincidence?
33:21
Okay, that's a really good question
33:22
Yeah, okay
33:24
Yup
33:26
So
33:30
you're absolutely right, okay?
33:31
So, luck is a form of strategy
33:35
okay?
33:36
Strategy
33:39
And all this is saying is that
33:41
you are trying to position yourself
33:43
in a place that allows you to get lucky
33:49
okay?
33:50
So
33:51
I left Canada
33:52
and I went to the United States because
33:53
I knew that in Canada
33:54
doesn't matter how hard you work
33:56
no one cares
33:58
But in the United States
33:59
if you work really hard
34:00
then you might get lucky and you might
34:02
meet someone who's like
34:03
wow, you're a really hard worker
34:04
I want to promote you
34:05
Okay?
34:06
So, so you're right in that
34:08
yes, you can strategize and increase your luck
34:13
but it's still luck
34:15
All right? And those who succeed
34:18
are able to think strategically and far ahead
34:23
and position themselves
34:25
in a way that allows them
34:27
to get lucky
34:29
Okay?
34:30
And they often have the characteristics that we talked about
34:32
you know, like, so self-control, resilience
34:36
and
34:36
the ability to look inward and better understand
34:39
what you're good at
34:41
Okay?
34:44
So it takes a combination of factors
34:46
But the point I'm trying to make is
34:48
that these people are only a minor
34:51
are a minority, okay?
34:53
One percent of the population
34:56
really
34:58
Okay? And they still depend on luck
35:01
Any more questions before I move on?
35:07
Okay, so this leads us to a question
35:11
which is, okay, well, the way that I frame everything
35:15
okay, the way that I frame everything
35:17
you have poor and you have rich
35:22
And as discussed, they live in their own world
35:25
world
35:25
and they don't really connect with each other
35:26
They have different parenting strategies
35:28
they have different outlooks
35:30
The rich stay with themselves
35:32
the poor stay amongst themselves
35:33
So this looks like a very stable system
35:35
right? Stability
35:38
Or the word we can use is equilibrium
35:44
Now the question then is
35:47
why do societies collapse?
35:50
Why are there revolutions?
35:52
Why are there social changes?
35:54
This looks like an
35:55
like a system of equilibrium where because of parenting
35:59
people know their place
36:00
and people know how to best
36:02
strategize about maintaining their place
36:06
So why are they
36:06
why is there social change?
36:10
And the reason why is that this system has problems
36:16
and it's stable, but the main problem is this system
36:20
okay?
36:21
It's, it's the rich that's problematic
36:23
And the reason why is that
36:25
the rich are taught from day
36:27
one to negotiate a better outcome
36:30
okay? So another, another
36:32
another way of saying this is that
36:33
the poor is like minimum
36:39
outcome, okay?
36:41
The rich want the maximum outcome
36:47
The poor are like
36:48
you know what, if I'm, you know, if I'm alive
36:51
if I have a decent job
36:54
I'm okay
36:55
But the rich are like
36:56
no, I need to be the top dog
36:59
I need to improve my lot in society
37:03
otherwise what's the point of my life?
37:05
Okay? So they have high expectations
37:07
okay?
37:07
High expectations
37:12
low expectations. Okay?
37:16
And this is a problem because power
37:22
it's a zero-sum game
37:25
Okay?
37:26
Hierarchy is a zero-sum game
37:27
So only a few people can be at
37:28
the top
37:30
So eventually
37:32
you get into a situation where there are too rich people
37:37
too many rich people
37:38
and not enough powerful positions
37:40
And this is what's called elite overproduction
37:49
Okay?
37:50
And then what happens here is that
37:52
in order to
37:56
get power
37:57
certain factions of the rich
37:59
will align with certain factions of the poor
38:01
against the powers that be
38:05
So all revolutions are always between the
38:11
half a lot versus half sum
38:14
It's never between rich and poor
38:17
It's always between half a lot
38:19
and half sum
38:22
So the people who led the Chinese Revolution
38:24
right, people like Mao Zedong
38:26
Zhou Enlai, Deng Xiaoping
38:27
they were not poor people
38:29
They didn't come from poor families
38:31
But they weren't rich enough
38:33
okay?
38:34
So the Chinese Revolution
38:35
was really between the urban elite versus the rural elite
38:41
okay? The have a lot versus have some
38:44
If you look at every revolution in human history
38:46
that's always been the case
38:50
okay?
38:50
If you go back to Chinese history and
38:52
look at all these revolutions that started in China
38:55
it was always led by
38:58
the middle class or the aspirational class
39:02
usually merchants, right?
39:04
Merchants, because they were discriminated heavily in society
39:09
but they had money
39:10
And they wanted to transform their money into
39:12
power. And so when times were bad
39:14
when people were looking for change
39:16
they took the initiative and led people into revolution
39:22
Okay?
39:27
Okay, does that make sense
39:28
guys?
39:32
All right, any questions?
39:40
All right
39:46
So you said the revolution was
39:48
initiated be, like within those rich people
39:52
so how could they lead the poor people to
39:54
to
39:55
to vote for them to start the revolution
39:57
if there's a revolution in a huge amount of people
40:00
like, like the public base to
40:04
like, yeah, to, to initiate?
40:07
Okay
40:10
Okay, great question
40:11
okay. So revolutions are almost the same
40:15
So over time, because of the structure
40:20
because of the inequality between rich and poor
40:22
certain problems arise, okay?
40:24
So, and these problems are extremely common
40:28
The first problem, okay, problems
40:32
The first problem is indebtedness
40:41
Because the rich have a monopoly over wealth
40:44
for the poor to survive
40:45
they need to borrow money
40:47
But over time, because of interest rates
40:54
the poor find themselves in slavery
40:58
okay?
41:01
Because you can't afford to pay back
41:04
The bank or the rich person
41:07
then your body is collateral
41:10
okay? So you become a slave
41:11
but not only do you become a slave
41:12
but your children become slaves as well
41:15
So slavery is a very common problem
41:17
And then the third issue
41:18
of course, is landlessness
41:25
Okay? So these are the three
41:27
most common
41:28
problems that ultimately become the seeds of revolution
41:34
the poor get into debt
41:36
and so they lose their land
41:37
and their children become slaves
41:39
And the children
41:40
their children's children become slaves as well
41:42
Okay? Because of interest rates
41:44
it's impossible for you to pay back
41:46
that debt
41:48
Okay?
41:49
So now you have a majority of people
41:51
who have actually no incentive to live
41:56
So what happens now is that
42:00
a elite, okay, okay, say to these people
42:08
follow me
42:10
into revolution and I will clear your debts
42:14
I will give you land
42:16
and I will end slavery
42:18
And that's it, okay?
42:21
Every single revolution has been like this
42:22
There have been different names
42:24
okay, so for example, communists are like
42:26
we'll create a communist paradise
42:28
What's a communist paradise? A communist paradise is
42:29
where debt is cancelled
42:31
where people are given land
42:33
and where no one's a slave
42:34
okay?
42:35
And others like, okay, we'll create a religious paradise
42:38
Islam, okay, so Mohammed
42:41
the Islamic revolution was about this
42:44
initially
42:44
Later on it changed
42:46
right?
42:47
And Mohammed said to everyone
42:48
we're going to create a kingdom of heaven
42:50
What's a kingdom of heaven?
42:50
A kingdom of heaven is where people
42:53
don't have debt
42:55
Where people have land to feed themselves
42:58
and where there are no slaves
43:00
So if you are a Muslim
43:01
you can never be a slave
43:04
Okay? So look at every single revolution
43:06
it's this pattern, whereas over time, because of inequality in society
43:11
you have, people who fall into too much debt
43:15
they become slaves, they have no land
43:18
and then because of elite overproduction
43:20
you have this faction that splinters off
43:23
and who, in order to, obtain power
43:28
get the people on their side
43:29
okay? And you look at the Roman Civil War
43:31
Julius Caesar was pow- was saying the same thing
43:35
right? Why was he so popular?
43:36
Because he was saying to the Roman people
43:39
if I become king
43:40
I will get rid of your debt
43:42
I will free you of slavery
43:43
and I will give you land
43:44
And that's why they had to kill him
43:46
Okay?
43:48
Why is almost twelve
43:50
so popular in America right now?
43:51
Same thing, man
43:52
Where Americans are in debt to their credit cards
43:57
student loans, their houses
43:59
and so
44:01
they believe that Donald Trump were to become in power
44:04
if he were to become king
44:05
what's the first thing that a king does?
44:06
What the first thing that a king always
44:08
does is cancel all debts
44:12
Because if you cancel all debts
44:13
who loses power?
44:14
It's the rich who lose power
44:16
And it's the rich who are most
44:18
dangerous to a king
44:20
Okay?
44:21
Does that make sense?
44:26
So again
44:26
this is a very similar pattern
44:28
in human history. It's all game theory
44:30
okay? Any more questions
44:35
guys?
44:40
Okay, ask one more question
44:41
then we'll break
44:42
okay? Is this clear to you guys?
44:46
Okay
44:47
So another way of understanding this is that
44:49
according to game theory
44:51
individuals don't really matter
44:53
okay? You have to look at large groups
44:55
you have to look at large
44:56
large social trends
44:57
okay? You cannot really change
45:00
the outcome for certain
45:03
groups of people like poor kids unless you
45:05
look at the overall structure in which they
45:09
they live
45:11
Okay. One more question
45:16
guys, then we'll break for the day
45:26
Yeah, Alan
45:33
So like
45:34
is that the
45:36
the society
45:38
or like just the elite that really rule the country
45:41
who really have the power
45:43
have the motivations to maintain a society
45:46
that a certain degree of social mobility is allowed
45:49
but not all of them
45:51
but, but, but not, really a big social mobility
45:55
so that first, firstly, they can maintain their power
45:58
but second, like
45:59
they give the
46:00
lower class people a hope to get into the rich class
46:06
but not using like revolutions
46:08
or
46:08
other things that will like turn the society into collapse
46:13
Okay, yeah
46:16
Okay, look, you're absolutely right
46:18
So social mobility is really the best form of governance
46:22
right?
46:24
As long as you
46:25
enable people with talent and ability
46:29
and ambition to climb up They'll be happy
46:34
and your society will be very stable
46:35
But not only will it be very stable
46:37
it'll be very prosperous
46:39
very creative
46:40
It doesn't matter what system you have
46:42
okay?
46:43
So the example is
46:44
okay, America in 1950s was a democracy
46:48
and there's a lot of social mobility
46:51
and so people worked really hard
46:53
and America became very wealthy
46:56
But guess what? In China
46:57
1950s, China was not a democracy
47:01
it was, it was a communist system
47:03
But in 1950s
47:05
people worked really hard as well
47:08
Why? Because China was destroyed after decades of war
47:12
and there were lots of
47:12
opportunities for social mobility. If you worked hard
47:15
you got promoted very quickly in the system
47:17
So even though it was a communist system
47:19
not a capitalist system
47:21
even though it was
47:21
it was, it was a com
47:22
command economy, rather than a democracy
47:24
people worked really hard because they thought that by working hard
47:29
they can improve their lives
47:31
So social mobility
47:33
is the best form of governance
47:34
You don't need democracy
47:35
you don't need any
47:37
any system, okay? As long as you have social mobility
47:39
people will be happy
47:41
The problem, though, is that over time
47:46
less than a generation
47:47
all the positions of power are failed
47:50
okay?
47:51
So the people with talent who made the country great
47:56
who made the country wealthy
47:57
when they, when they get into the power
48:01
they don't want people like them to replace them
48:06
they want their children to replace them
48:10
okay?
48:11
And over time, these children are a lot
48:15
So what happens is at the very top
48:17
all the positions are filled
48:19
and there's a waiting list as well
48:22
So if you are a poor person who is
48:26
who works hard, really talented, Unfortunately
48:31
all those positions at the top are filled
48:33
already
48:34
And the wait, and there's also a waiting list
48:36
so too bad
48:37
Okay? And this is
48:39
and again, you just look at Chinese history
48:40
right?
48:41
Look at Chinese history
48:42
where at the beginning of the dynasty
48:44
you had all these talented people take the civil
48:47
civil entrance examination, the keju
48:50
and these are really top people
48:53
But then what happens is that they
48:56
they have children
48:56
and they teach their children how to do on the keju
48:59
and then eventually they're like
49:00
you know what, we'll just cheat
49:01
So they corrupt the keju
49:04
and then eventually like
49:05
you know what, screw this
49:06
whoever can pay
49:08
to pass the keju will pass the keju
49:10
And then all the positions at the very top are filled
49:15
there's no more sociability
49:16
so what do people do?
49:17
They engage in revolution
49:19
right?
49:20
So you look at Hong Xiuquan
49:24
right?
49:25
He, he failed the keju
49:27
Or he, there was no position at the top for him
49:30
so he started
49:31
so he believed he became one of the brother of Jesus
49:33
right?
49:34
And he started this revolution
49:35
that claimed tens of millions of lives in
49:37
China
49:39
Why? Because there was no social mobility for
49:40
him
49:41
Fifty years ago, prior, he would have been a
49:43
he would have been a civil servant
49:46
Same thing for Mao Zedong
49:48
right?
49:49
By the time that Mao Zedong became a university student
49:53
the could you have been eliminated
49:55
So there's no way for him to climb the ladder anymore
49:58
therefore he had to start engaging in
50:01
new ideas
50:04
Okay?
50:06
So you're absolutely right in that social
50:08
social mobility
50:09
is the best way to maintain social harmony
50:14
But people have children
50:16
and they want their children to succeed
50:18
and they will arrange a system in a
50:20
way that only their children can succeed
50:23
which screws over every other children
50:25
every, everyone else
50:27
and so they have no choice but to overflow the system
50:30
okay?
50:31
Or another thing this is game reset
50:39
Game reset
50:43
This is what a revolution is
50:44
okay?
50:45
So another way
50:47
another way of saying this is that
50:49
100 people are playing a game
50:51
10 people are winning
50:54
and they keep on winning
50:55
and they can only win
50:56
so everyone else is like
50:58
screw this game, let's start a new game
51:01
And the 10 people are like
51:02
no, we're happy playing this game
51:04
They can't agree, so the United People can only
51:06
the only thing they can do is a revolution
51:10
which allows for game reset
51:12
which will now again allows for social mobility
51:18
And that is the course of human history
51:21
Okay?
51:24
Either you
51:27
climb up the ladder
51:29
if they don't allow you to climb up the ladder
51:30
then you should break the game
51:33
Okay, so, but unfortunately, again
51:37
once you're in power
51:39
you want your children to inherit your power
51:42
and so you will rig the game in
51:43
a way that only your children can succeed
51:46
Okay?
51:46
And that's why the school
51:48
that's why the schools are the way they are
51:51
Okay, schools for the rich are very different from the
51:54
very different from schools for the poor
51:55
right?
51:56
Schools for the rich
51:58
there's a lot of freedom
52:00
there's a lot of creativity
52:01
the teachers are very good
52:03
You go to poor schools
52:04
and it's the complete opposite
52:05
And the reason why is
52:07
the system is set up to make sure
52:08
that certain people succeed
52:10
and everyone else fails
52:13
Okay?
52:14
Does that make sense
52:15
Alan?
52:16
Okay, great
52:17
Any more questions, guys?
52:19
All right
52:20
Good. I'll see you guys next class
52:21
okay?

Watch these videos on your TV

XTTV brings video content from X to your living room. Download now and start watching on the big screen.